Detection of Early Gastric Cancer: Overestimation of the Role of Mass-Screening

Suzuki Haruhisa,Gotoda Takuji,Saito Daizo,Sasako Mitsuru
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gie.2006.03.266
IF: 10.396
2006-01-01
Gastrointestinal Endoscopy
Abstract:Background: The prognosis of advanced gastric cancer remains poor, and to reduce its mortality the disease should be detected at an early stage. A nationwide mass-screening program for gastric cancer has started in 1960 employing photofluorography. The 5-year survival rate in 1960's was about 40%, which has become over 70% after 1990. The proportion of early gastric cancer (EGC) changed from 15% to 50% in these periods. Together with extended lymph node dissection, mass-screening has been attributed to this significant improvement of survival of those with gastric cancer in Japan. However, more and more patients are diagnosed to have EGC outside of mass-screening. The aim of this study is to review whether the patients have any symptoms or not at the time of early detection, and by what means these tumors were detected. Patients and Methods: From 2001 to 2003, 1226 patients (male:female ratio; 2.2:1, age ranged from 26-95 years) with EGC were treated at National Cancer Center Hospital, Tokyo (NCCH). We reviewed their medical records. Results: Among 1226 patients with EGC, 512 (41.8%) were symptomatic, while 714 (58.2%) reported no symptoms. Of the symptomatic patients, 468 ones (91.4%) were examined at outpatient clinics, 39 (7.6%) were investigated by health check up and 5 (1.0%) were participating in mass-screening program. The commonest chief complaints at presentation were epigastric pain, gastric discomfort or hunger pain reported by 376 patients (73.4%) of the symptomatic patients. 91.6% of the symptomatic patients directly underwent esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD), while X-ray was the initial assessment in only 8.4% of them. In contrast, of the asymptomatic patients, 320 ones (44.8%) were examined at outpatient clinics, 306 ones (42.9%) were investigated by health check up and 88 ones (12.3%) were participating in mass-screening program. EGD was the initial assessment in 67.8%, while X-ray was the initial assessment in only 32.2% of asymptomatic patients. Conclusion: Majority of patients with EGC were detected outside of mass-screening program. This suggests that Japanese people and Japanese physicians are well aware of the risk of gastric cancer and the importance of early detection, which has more important role in early detection than mass screening.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?