Abstract:Having read your Editorial entitled “Psychiatric institutions in China” (July 3, p 2),1The LancetPsychiatric institutions in China.Lancet. 2010; 376: 2Scopus (1) Google Scholar we are upset about the misfortune of the farmer. However, as psychiatrists from China we do not agree with the conclusion that psychiatric hospitals in the country are used to prevent people from exercising their freedom of expression. We believe that the reasons behind this tragedy should be explored rather than blame simply apportioned to the Chinese government. Civil servants in the local town authority forged the supporting documents after a land dispute with the farmer and his friend, and then sent them to a psychiatric hospital. After admission, the farmer was diagnosed with “paranoid psychosis” and received involuntary treatment, as reported in the newspaper. However, we should emphasise that this was a crime committed by local civil servants and cannot lead to the conclusion that psychiatric hospitals in China are used for political purposes. As far as we know, in recent years there have only been occasional cases of compulsory admissions to psychiatric hospitals, usually related to family economic conflicts. Hence, we see no evidence to support the Editorial's conclusion that there are many such tragic cases in China. One likely reason for this case is the lack of a national mental health act in China. In 1985, a committee started drafting such an act, with the draft revised 15 times until 2005.2Yan DX Wang J Chen ZW Chinese Mental Health Act after 24 years of giving birth will be born during the year.China Newsweek. 2009; June 26; (in Chinese).Google Scholar Unfortunately, the final version is yet to be released. At this point, there are no national guidelines on involuntary psychiatric admissions. People who are suspected of having psychiatric disorders are often compulsorily admitted to psychiatric hospitals with consent forms signed by relatives. Homeless people suspected of having psychiatric disorders are often certified for psychiatric treatment by local civil and public security departments.3Yu CH Wang HQ Sun W Liu DH Analyses of admission of homeless psychiatric patients (in Chinese).Med J Chinese People's Health. 2007; 19: 756-757Google Scholar It is sometimes unclear who should apply for the discharge of the “patient”. The principle in many regions of China is that the person who signed the consent form for admission should apply for the discharge.4Shen XW China's Mental Health Act is not released after twenty-five years' drafting, and compulsory admission leading to a debate.China Newsweek. 2010; June 3; (in Chinese).Google Scholar This could explain why the farmer was detained in the psychiatric hospital for 6 years. To avoid similar cases, the national mental health legislation should be finalised and implemented as soon as possible. In addition, we would like to call for continual monitoring by the media and improved ethical training for mental health professionals. We declare that we have no conflicts of interest.

Compulsory treatment of mentally ill offenders in Hunan 2005-2009

Status of mandatory treatment of mentally ill offenders without criminal responsibility in China: Information from 5,262 mandatory treatment judgments

Stigmatizing Attitudes Towards Mental Disorders among Non-Mental Health Professionals in Six General Hospitals in Hunan Province

Prevalence of mental disorders in the male juvenile detention centers of Hunan and Sichuan

An investigation of Chinese psychiatrists' attitude to mentally ill person and their disposing policies in the three sites of China

The Implementation of China's Mental Health Law-Defined Risk Criteria for Involuntary Admission: A National Cross-Sectional Study of Involuntarily Hospitalized Patients.

Profiles of Psychiatric Disorders among Heroin Dependent Individuals in Changsha, China.

Mental Health Literacy Survey of Non-Mental Health Professionals in Six General Hospitals in Hunan Province of China

Compliance with the Criteria of Involuntary Admission in China's Mental Health Law: a National Cross-Sectional Study of Patients Admitted to Hospital Involuntarily

A review of the new provisions for sanctioning mentally disordered offenders in China, in a broader historical context

A Multilevel Cross-Sectional Study of Mental Disorder in Community Settings in Zhejiang Province

Treatment dropout of patients in National Continuing Management and Intervention Program for Psychoses in Guangdong Province from 2006 to 2009: Implication for mental health service reform in China

A Retrospective Study on Recidivism in Patients with Mental Disorders

An investigation of involuntary admission criterion for patients with mental disorders in psychiatrists in Shanghai

Compulsory Admission to Psychiatric Hospitals in China

The Comparison of Disposal Attitudes Towards Forensic Psychiatric Patients among Police Officers, Psychiatrists and Community Members in China.

A Comparison Study of Persons Found not Criminally Responsible by Reason of Mental Disorder between British Columbia, Canada and Hunan, China

Analysis on the correlative characteristics of mental disorder patients with illegal behaviors

Relation Factors of the Criminal Responsibility in the Offenders with Mental Disorders by the Discriminatory Analysis

The compulsory psychiatric regime in Hong Kong: Constitutional and ethical perspectives

Attitude and implementation of clinical staffs on participation in treatment of patients with psychotic illness