Mo1521 Endomicroscopy: Interobserver Agreement and Accuracy in Prediction of Intraepithelial Neoplasia in the Upper and Lower GI-Tract

Ralf Kiesslich,Arthur Hoffman,Marcia Canto,Kerry B. Dunbar,Yan-Qing Li,Thorsten Hansen,Michael Vieth,Martin Goetz,Peter R. Galle
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gie.2011.03.820
IF: 10.396
2011-01-01
Gastrointestinal Endoscopy
Abstract:Confocal laser endomicroscopy (CLE) enables in vivo histology during ongoing endoscopy at subcellular resolution. Cellular and vascular patterns can be imaged and distinct changes are associated with neoplasia. However, data on interobserver agreement and accuracy for diagnosing intraepithelial neoplasia in the upper and lower GI-tract are still limited. AIM: We assessed the interobserver agreement and accuracy for predicting intraepithelial neoplasia (esophagus, stomach, colon) for three different examiner groups (medical students with no experience of CLE; endoscopists with experience in CLE, and GI-pathologists). All participants received a 30 minute introduction explaining the technique of CLE as well as the available diagnostic criteria before starting the computer-based endomicroscopic image judgment. 75 high quality CLE images with and without intraepithelial neoplasia captured by one expert (RK) using the Pentax endomicroscope (eCLE) were selected for evaluation. A total of nine examiners (3 students, 3 endoscopists, 3 pathologists) reviewed the images and determined whether neoplasia was present using the Mainz classifications for Barrett's esophagus and Colon Cancer. Gastric neoplasia was evaluated using the Qilu classification. The interobserver agreement was calculated using the kappa statistic. Accuracy was determined as the proportion correct answers compared with histology as the reference standard. A sample size of at least 70 endomicroscopic images was calculated based on 95% confidence interval, estimated kappa of 0.8, standard error of 0.15 and neoplasia present in 1/3 of images for 9 raters. see tableTabled 1Interobserver variation of Endomicroscopy.kappa valuesaccuracyEsophagusStomachColonEsophagusStomachColonStudents0.530.680.7477%84%88%Endoscopists0.490.910.8075%96%91%Pathologists0.350.630.7567%83%88% Open table in a new tab Endoscope-based endomicroscopy prediction of intraepithelial neoplasia in the upper and lower GI-tract is associated with high accuracy and substantial to almost perfect interobserver agreement for gastric and colonic neoplasia independent from the experience level in endomicroscopy or pathology. However, Barrett's associated neoplasia is more difficult to interpret and showed only moderate agreement.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?