The Measurement for Absolute Thresholds of the Z(o)llner Illusion

邓雅菱,刘宛灵,周仁来

2013-01-01

Abstract:It is quite natural that we erroneously perceive what we see and we can hardly correct the image even if we have noticed that we are wrong,which is how visual illusions occur.Since last century,researchers have already studied the relationship between figure images and human behavior,the perceptional processing that affects visual illusion,and the neuron system that determines it.Ironically, few of them considered the trigger condition or elements required when we want illusions to occur,and few of them focused on the famous Zllner illusion even if they discovered how the optical features influence the amount of illusion.So what we are curious about is the condition that determines it.In other words,we are to measure the absolute threshold of the Zllner illusion.In terms of the method, since our vision system is trying to modify the image in our eyes in order to be more accurate,the methods used in the past have serious problems because participants had to adjust to the stimuli figure for a quite long time.Therefore,the minimal - change method is much better for threshold measuring where participants should respond in a fixed short period of time. In Experiment 1,the variable is the quantity of interfering lines.In Experiment 2,the variable is the gap between the main line and the interfering lines.In Experiment 3,the variable is the distance between the two main lines.Among every three figures,two are signal(the true Zllner illusion whose main lines are parallel) and one is noise(the false Zllner illusion whose main lines seem parallel but actually are unparallel).Participants need to answer whether it looks parallel or not according to their very first sensation. By comparing the three experiments,we found that figures with 45 degrees orientation was more falsely perceived,which shows the same results as the past findings and fMRI support.In addition,anticipation error causes significant differences between increasing and decreasing blocks in all experiments.We further analyzed the starting figures,that are exactly the same in these three experiments,and surprisingly found that they were perceived to be completely different,supporting that anticipation error should not be ignored.We believe it is the false attention distribution that causes the error,and this error may be a remarkable feature to distinguish between normal perception and illusive perception. To summarize,the Zllner illusion only occurs when:1) there are more than 5 or 7 pairs of interfering lines in 45 and 90 degrees orientation;2) the gap between the interfering lines and the main line is less than 6.58 or 4.48 pixels each;3) and the distance between the two main lines is less than 124.44 or 131.73 pixels each.Besides,we find that:4) the studied variables can determine the Zllner illusion in this strong - to - weak order:the quantity of interfering lines,the distance between the two main lines,and the gap between the main line and the interfering lines;5) when the orientation of the main lines is 45 degrees,illusions occur generally easier than when they are 90 degrees;6) in the perception of the Zllner illusion,anticipation error is quite severe.