Abstract:Purpose The binding energy of ions on soils is one of the most important parameters to quantify the sorption strength of ions on soils. The aim of this study was to determine the mean free binding energies of four divalent cations Ca 2+ , Cd 2+ , Cu 2+ , and Pb 2+ in suspensions of yellow-brown soil and black soils clay particles through ion activity and Wien effect methods, respectively, and to justify which method will be positive. Materials and methods The homoionic suspensions of yellow-brown soil (YB) and two black soils (BS I , BS II ), which were saturated with divalent cations Ca 2+ , Cd 2+ , Cu 2+ , and Pb 2+ , were allowed to stand for 7 to 10 days and to achieve sufficient equilibration of ion reactions in the suspensions. The same sample was used to prepare two suspensions: one for the Wien effect measurement and another for the ion activity measurement, and the binding energies of divalent cations on yellow-brown soil and black soils that were determined by the two methods were calculated and compared. Results and discussion The mean Gibbs free binding energies values (ΔG bi ) of Ca 2+ , Cu 2+ , and Pb 2+ on YB and BS I determined by ion activity method are obviously greater than ones by Wien effect method. The ΔG bi values (I) of Cd 2+ , Cu 2+ , and Pb 2+ to subsamples of black soil II determined by ion activity method are also larger than ones (II) by Wien effect method, the values (I) of the three cations for top black soil II were in the order Pb (14 kJ mol −1 ) > Cu (9 kJ mol −1 ) > Cd (7 kJ mol −1 ), and the values for bottom black soil II and OM-free black soil II were in the order Pb (14–16 kJ mol −1 ) > Cu (11–13 kJ mol −1 ) ≈ Cd (11–13 kJ mol −1 ). The ratios (I/II) of ΔG bi are in the range of 1.3–2.4 except the suspensions of Cd-top black soil II in which I/II value is equal to about 1. Conclusions The mean Gibbs free binding energies between divalent cations and soil particles determined by ion activity method were larger than those determined by Wien effect method. The Wien effect method supported by the results acquired from atom absorption spectrum is the better method to determine the binding energies of divalent cations to soil particles because the activities of divalent cations in suspensions determined by ion activity method were underestimated.

Wien Effect Determination of Adsorption Energies Between Heavy Metal Ions and Soil Particles

Wien Effect Measurements in Soil Colloidal Suspensions: A Novel Method for Characterizing the Interactions between Charged Particles and Counter Ions

Wien Effect Characterization of Interactions Between Ions and Charged Sites on Clay Surfaces of Variable-Charge Soils

Wien effect in suspensions and its application in soil science: A review

Comparison between ion activity method and suspension Wien effect method in determining binding energy of divalent cations to soil particles

ENERGY RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CATIONS AND SOIL CLAY PARTICLES AS INFERRED FROM THE WIEN EFFECT IN DILUTE SUSPENSIONS

Exploring the Distribution of Zn(2+)in Inner and Outer Helmholtz Planes of the Electrical Double Layer of Soil Based on Wien Effect

Negative Wien Effect Measurements for Exploring Polarization Processes of Cations Interacting with Negatively Charged Soil Particles

Wien Effect of Cd/Zn on Soil Clay Fraction and Their Interaction

Effects of Soil Organic Matter on Sorption of Metal Ions on Soil Clay Particles

Binding and Adsorption Energy of Cd in Soils and Its Environmental Implication for Cd Bioavailability

Removal of Heavy Metal from Aqueous Solutions Using Chinese Loess Soil

Effect of Organic Matter on Sorption of Zn on Soil: Elucidation by Wien Effect Measurements and EXAFS Spectroscopy.

Adsorption behavior of co-existing Mn(II) and Cr(III) in loess soil

Binding Energies of Monovalent Anions with Fe/Al Oxides Based on Ion Activity and Suspension Wien Effect Methods

Organo-Modification Effects on Soil Particles-Inorganic Cations Interactions As Revealed by Wien Effect Measurements

Evaluating the Fraction of Electrically Associated Cations on Surfaces of Soil Particles by Extrapolation of Strong-Field Wien Effect Measurements in Dilute Suspensions

Wien Effect Determination of Binding and Adsorption Energies Between Positively Charged Nano-Particles and Anions

Adsorption/Desorption Kinetics of Zn in Soils: Influence of Phosphate

Kinetic study on removal of heavy metal ions from aqueous solution by using soil

Exploring the Effect of Organic Matter on the Interactions Between Mineral Particles and Cations with Wien Effect Measurements