Abstract:Search engines, referrals services, advisors, and other forms of information gatekeepers and recommenders, are omnipresent in today's information-heavy economy. These services widely employ sponsored recommendations, wherein merchants pay the recommender in return for favorable placement in recommender's list. We develop and analyze an economic model of sponsored search on recommenders, in a setting where consumers cannot a priori discern low and high quality merchants or recall all the relevant merchants. Our model extends traditional advertising literature by incorporating an intelligent recommender who aims to advice and influence consumers, while also serving as an advertising platform for merchants. We find that an intelligent recommender not only makes consumers better-informed, but may also cause merchants to modify their price-advertising strategies in a way that favors consumers. Depending on the cost and quality differences between the merchants, the sponsored result may either serve a quality signaling role, or enable the recommender to exploit its leverage in making consumers aware of the merchant. As the recommender technology becomes more accurate at discerning firms' quality, the signaling demand reduces. However the recommender then becomes more capable of coercing lower quality firms to pay for inclusion in the search results. The recommender's overall advertising revenue increases; product prices drop due to a shift in the the higher quality firm's signaling effort from price to advertising; and consumer surplus increases. Our analysis assumes an advertising-based business model. When the recommender lacks sufficient pricing power over sponsored results, a higher accuracy level may lower advertising revenue and consumer welfare, hence the recommender should consider other revenue sources.

User Motivations and Incentive Structures in an Online Recommender System

An Economic Model of User Rating in an Online Recommender System.

Nonmonetary Rewards of Referral Reward Programs and Recommendation Intention: the Role of Reward–product Congruity

An Incentive Model for Voting Based on Information-Hiding in P2P Networks.

Rethinking Incentives in Recommender Systems: Are Monotone Rewards Always Beneficial?

User Participation in Collaborative Filtering-Based Recommendation Systems: A Game Theoretic Approach

The Economics of Recommender Systems: Evidence from a Field Experiment on MovieLens

Social Comparisons and Contributions to Online Communities: A Field Experiment on MovieLens

Incentive-Aware Recommender Systems in Two-Sided Markets

The Informational Role of Online Recommendations: Evidence from a Field Experiment

Who Should Be Given Incentives? Counterfactual Optimal Treatment Regimes Learning for Recommendation

Modelling the Recommender Alignment Problem

Motivating User Contributions in Online Knowledge Communities: Virtual Rewards and Reputation

An enhanced social matrix factorization model for recommendation based on social networks using social interaction factors

Recommending to Strategic Users

User Participation Game in Collaborative Filtering

Modeling Recommender Ecosystems: Research Challenges at the Intersection of Mechanism Design, Reinforcement Learning and Generative Models

Exploring Mental Models for Transparent and Controllable Recommender Systems: A Qualitative Study

Rating Prediction in Recommender Systems Based on User Behavior Probability and Complex Network Modeling

A Model of Sponsored Results in Intelligent Recommenders and Search Engines

Incentivizing Agents through Ratings