Effect of Water Quality on Earthy-musty Off-flavor in Hypophthalmichthys molitrix from Yangcheng West Lake
Jian-ming ZHU,Chun-fang CAI,Chao YANG,Yuan-tu YE,Qian ZHANG,Tao WU,Ting LI,Hong-wei GONG,Quan-lin WANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.15928/j.1674-3075.2015.02.014
2015-01-01
Abstract:Silver carp and bighead carp can suppress the occurrence of algae bloom by filter feeding plankton.How-ever,the production of these species in eutrophic water body is hampered by the problem of a muddy off-flavor that profoundly affects consumer acceptance and commodity value.A recent study has identified the main substances re-sponsible for the muddy off-flavor are geosmin (GSM)and 2-methylisoborneol (2-MIB).In this investigation we determined GSM and 2-MIB in silver carp farmed in Yangcheng West Lake in Suzhou City,Jiangsu Province and monitored the water quality parameters of the lake to study the relationship of the muddy off-flavor with water quali-ty.A depuration trial was also carried out to assess the effectiveness of the process for removal of the off-flavor.Six enclosures (A-F)were set in Yangcheng West Lake with respective areas of 167,453,567,190,1 000 and 400 hm2 .The fry of silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix),bighead carp and other species fish were cultured together in the enclosures from the beginning of 2009 .The fish were harvested near to Spring Festival of the next year and new fry were subsequently added to the enclosures.Total nitrogen (TN),total phosphorus (TP),chemi-cal oxygen demand (CODMn )and Chlorophyll a (Chl-a)were monitored in each enclosure from April,2009 to No-vember,2011.Ten silver carp were sampled from each enclosure in May 2012 and the level of GSMand 2-MIB in muscle tissue were determined.Seventy silver carp (about 1 .0 kg each)were caught from enclosure A (with the lowest water quality)for depuration trials.Five silver carps were placed in each water tank(140 cm ×100 cm × 70 cm)with tap water and aerated continually.The water was changed daily and the trial lasted 32 days,from May 29th to June 29th of 2012.At 0,1,2,4,8,16,32 d of the depuration period,nine silver carps were randomly selected and GSMand 2-MIB were determined.Average concentrations of TN,TP,CODMn from 2009 to 2011 were 2.80,0.23,6.01 mg/L and the concentration of Chl-a was 34.4 μg/L,indicating that water quality in Yangcheng West Lake was lower than Grade V,while the concentration of Chl-a was below the threshold for algae blooms.The concentrations of GSMand 2-MIB in muscle tissue of silver carp were high,with maximum values both occurring in enclosure A (7.98 μg/kg;7.28 μg/kg)and minimum values both in enclosure C (5.27 μg/kg;4.53 μg/kg).Muscle concentrations of GSM and 2-MIB were positively correlated with concentrations of TN,TP and Chl-a in the lake water.The concentrations of GSMand 2-MIB were reduced by 55%and 72%after eight days of depuration.After 32 days of depuration,concentrations of GSM and 2-MIB in silver carps were below detectable levels.Results suggest that algae blooms were controlled by releasing filter-feeding fish in Yangcheng West Lake. The muddy off-flavor of silver carps was related with water quality but can be removed by 32 days of depuration.