The Relationship between Managers' Emotional Intelligence and Performance:Evidence of Direct and Mediated Effects
Zhang Huihua,Li Aimei,Ling Wenquan,Xu Bo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2009.03.014
2009-01-01
Abstract:Although the relationship between emotional intelligence and performance has been discussed widely in literature,there are few studies probing the impact and mechanism of managers' emotional intelligence on performance from an empirical perspective.In order to fill this gap in the literature,this article examines the direct and mediated effects of a behavior-based measure of managers' emotional intelligence on performance.The paper presents three studies based on a sample of managers.The first study investigates the direct effects of managers' emotional intelligence on subjective performance,as well as the mediated effects of leadership competence and management self-efficacy,using a sample of 320 managers and self-assessment questionnaires.The second study investigates the direct effects of managers' emotional intelligence on objective performance using third-party reports of managers' emotional intelligence as the independent variable,and the ratio of key performance indices as the dependent variable for a sample of 12 managers.The third study investigates the direct effects of managers' emotional intelligence on subjective performance,as well as the mediated effects of leadership competence in a sample of 65 managers with 850 third-party questionnaire responses.Multi-source data are collected from managers themselves,as well as from their subordinates,peers,superiors and work units by means of managers' emotional intelligence behavior questionnaires,PM leader behavior questionnaires,management self-efficacy questionnaires and subjective performance questionnaires in composed of task performance,contextual performance and management effectiveness dimension and objective performance questionnaires reflected by the accomplished ratio of key performance index.Correlation analysis,regression analysis and structural equation modeling analysis are employed to analyze the survey data.The results show that managers' emotional intelligence significantly and positively impacts performance,and leadership competence partly mediates the positive relationship between managers' emotional intelligence and subjective perfor-mance,as well as management self-efficacy.Lastly,the practical implications of these findings are discussed along with the study limitations.At the same time,further areas for research are identified including exploring the relationship between managers' emo-tional intelligence and performance when controlling for cognitive ability and personality,as well as considering other moderating and mediating variables.