A new interpretation of the conventional thermobarometry in eclogite: Evidence from the calculated PT pseudosections.

WEI ChunJing,SU XiangLi,LOU YuXing,LI Yanjuan
IF: 1.468
2009-01-01
Acta Petrologica Sinica
Abstract:The garnet-clinopyroxene (GC) thermometer and garnet-clinopyroxene-phengite( GCP) barometer are commonly used for determining the PT conditions of eclogite metamorphism. These thermobarometries are calibrated from the exchange and net transfer reactions among the phase components in garnet, clinopyroxene and phengite. The calculated PT pseudosections from a MORB composition indicate that in different eclogite assemblages there are different exchange and net transfer reactions among the phase components to control the compositions of the three minerals: In the chlorite-, talc- and glaucophane-bearing low-T eclogites, the Mg-contents in garnet and omphacite are dependent on the dehydrations of hydrous minerals, increasing as temperature rise, and the Fe-Mg exchange reaction between garnet and omphacite plays a trivial role. Thus, in the natural low-T eclogites which contain glaucophane and other hydrous minerals, omphacite is usually rich in Mg, which may result in the GC thermometer giving lower temperature results. In the lawsonite-bearing HP-UHP eclogites, the Ca-contents in garnet are dependent on the proportions of lawsonite, decreasing as pressure rise or temperature decrease. In this case, the net transfer reactions among garnet, omphacite and phengite may have a minor effect on the garnet compositions, and the GCP barometer may give lower pressure results due to garnet poor-in Ca. In the medium-T kyanite-bearing UP-UHP eclogites, the garnet, omphacite and phengite compositions are largely controlled by the Fe-Mg exchange reactions between garnet and omphacite, and the net transfer reactions in garnet- omphacite- phengite- kyanite- quartz / coesite. Thus, both GC thermometer and GCP barometer can give available PT results. In the lower-P hornblende-bearing eclogite, the Mg-contents in garnet and omphacite mainly reflect pressure changes, and commonly do not reflect temperature variations. The average PT mode (avPT) in Thermocalc could give available temperature results, and relatively lower pressures similar to those from the GCP barometer for the glaucophane-bearing low-T eclogites, but could not yield reasonable PT formation for the medium-T kyanite eclogites without the hydrous minerals such as glaucophane and epidote etc. Comparatively, the pseudosection thermobarometry can provide much more PT formation, and is the most optimal method for determining the metamorphic PT conditions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?