University spin-offs: Opportunity or challenge?

Xiaogang Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nmat1790

IF: 41.2

2006-01-01

Nature Materials

Abstract:With industrial research increasingly under pressure to produce rapid profits, and universities rightly concerned with primary research, can university spin-off companies fill the gap between invention and commercialization?

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Facilitators of formation of spin-offs in university-industry collaboration

Zhang Li,Nie Ming

DOI: https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2009.03.020

2009-01-01

Abstract:The knowledge transfer in university-industry collaboration promotes the process of knowledge commercialization,and it strengthens the national and regional economic competitiveness,so it draws the most attention from academics and becomes one of focuses in current research.Spin-off activity is just an effective way to measure technology transfer,and its outcome satisfied most of us.The organizations of university-industry collaboration are "seedbed" of spin-offs.From views of organizations of university-industry collaboration,the extant literature on this topic is analyzed,and facilitators of spin-offs in university-industry collaboration are synthesized,then data are collected from organizations of university-industry collaboration representing different industrial sectors.The logistic regression model is used to test the hypotheses,it sheds more light on the facilitators of spin-offs.Determinants of spin-offs should be optimized according to the result by university heads and policy makers,and comments and suggestions are also offered.
Barriers to entrepreneurial growth: an empirical study on university spin‐offs in China

Yuan Zhou,Guannan Xu,Jun Su,Tim Minshall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/17585521111167289

2011-10-11

Journal of Science and Technology Policy in China

Abstract:Purpose Literature shows that university spin‐offs (USOs) have idiosyncratic strengths in comparison to other new firms; however, evidence also shows that Chinese USOs have a low survival rate, and only a small percent of them can grow into sustainable businesses. The purpose of this paper is to conduct an empirical study to inquire about the variable growth barriers to Chinese USOs, in order to address two major research questions of this paper: what are the major growth barriers, and how significant they are; and what supports should university and government provide to eliminate those barriers? Design/methodology/approach In the first place, this paper attempts to explore the research questions through literature review and pilot interviews, based on which, a questionnaire for a survey was developed. Then, this study then attempts to address the research questions through a nation‐wide survey in 2009 across 69 national university science parks. Findings This paper finds that corporate governance issues, managerial concerns, and lack of infrastructure support are three major categories of barriers that thwart the growth of USOs in China. In addition, this paper also identified the support that is expected from universities and government agencies in order to cope with the barriers. Originality/value This paper contributes to theory in three ways. First, it tests and validates some existing conceptual frameworks concerned with the growth barriers to USOs. Second, it sheds light on the specific growth concerns of Chinese USOs and identifies three kinds of barriers. Further, this study provides evidence for future policy making regarding USOs and university technology transfer activities in China. This research will be of interest to policy makers, academic entrepreneurs, and university administrators.
A Literature Review on the University Spin-off Company

LI Zhi-gang,SUN Xiu-mei,LIU Zhen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-5097.2012.01.030

2012-01-01

Abstract:University spin-off company is an important kind of entrepreneurial activities.It is also an effective way of knowledge transformation and technology commercialization.Moreover,it has an important role in constructing regional innovation system.The university spin-off phenomenon appears very early in west countries,and there are many related-researches.This article is a systematic literature review of university spin-off theories,including the concepts,types,the typical patterns,development processes,driving factors and the performance evolution,in order to explore the research achievement of the studies on the university spin-off company.Finally,it presents the suggestions for future research.
University spin-offs: the past, the present, and the future

Marina Dabić,Božidar Vlačić,Maribel Guerrero,Tugrul U. Daim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2022.2122656

2022-09-15

Studies in Higher Education

Abstract:This paper examines the past and present of the university spin-off (USO) phenomenon by identifying research findings and synthesizing different spin-off practices from around the globe. The evolution and future of this phenomenon are then discussed, alongside potential new lines of research. This study adopts a systematic literature review approach, combined with a Multiple Correspondence Analysis. This approach allows for the creation of a robust and reliable synthesis of the research carried out over the past 35 years (1986–2020), offering a fine-grained depiction of the USOs' underlying relationships through multiple correspondence analysis (MCA). This paper contributes to scholarly literature on academic entrepreneurship by providing insights into the analytical trends of the past, current evidence on the configuration of USOs, and discussions of the future of USO research. Several implications for improving performance, productivity, and reinforcing capabilities emerge to assist spin-off CEOs, university managers, and policymakers. This paper fulfils an identified need by revealing the trajectory of the USO research field. Additionally, it presents an up-to-date reflection of USO antecedents, decisions, and outcomes, outlining an agenda for future research.

education & educational research
Research on the Relationship of Institutional Innovation, Organizational Learning and Synergistic Effect: an Empirical Study of Chineses University Spin-Offs

Zhang Hao,Ding Yunlong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3926/jiem.950

2014-01-01

Abstract:Purpose: At present, the Central Government of China pays more attention to the synergistic innovation, and the national strategy policy of "innovation driven development" are made to implementations. Thus, the university plays an important role in the national innovation system, so that how the university gets involved in innovative activities becomes the primary problem of innovation strategy. This paper utilizes Chinese university spin-offs survey data to identify the influence process from institutional innovation and organizational learning to synergistic effect of organization.Design/methodology/approach: Firstly, we found that following the procedural view, each one of these three elements can be divided into two parts. Then, we established structural equation modeling with the connections between these six subdivisions. Secondly, by taking 270 university Spin-offs in China as samples, we verified the fit of the model through statistical data on the questionnaire survey. Thirdly, we analyzed the relationship and influence path of the institutional innovation, organizational learning and synergistic effect.Findings: The results of empirical research show that institutional implementation process is positive correlation on both sides of synergistic effect, and, the intermediary role is obvious that external organizational learning played a regulatory role between institutional innovation synergistic effects.Research limitations/implications: A large-scale questionnaire survey showed that the influence path of "institutions - organization-innovation performance" are existed. Therefore, the system analysis framework should be introduced to the emergence and development of University spin-offs, and further explored the synergistic process of institutional change and organizational evolution.Practical implications: University spin-offs are a mode of university - industry cooperation, and it takes participation in market competition also as enterprise. This result of study pointed that. "Institutions" and "organizations" are the two important factors in synergistic innovation, so the synergy mechanism design should be followed by the interaction relationship between these two above.Originality/value: Synergistic innovation is the guidance theory which leads the development trend of university-industrial cooperation in China. In this paper, the "institution" and "organization", as the two primary elements, are introduced to analyze the process of synergistic innovation. Then, the authors discussed the role of the "institutional innovation" and "organizational learning" in the process of synergistic innovation, aimed at study on the operational mechanism of the influence factors.
Building Global Products and Competing in Innovation: the Role of Chinese University Spin-Outs and Required Innovation Capabilities

Yuan Zhou,Tim Minshall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1504/ijtm.2014.059929

2014-01-01

International Journal of Technology Management

Abstract:Usually, firms that produce innovative global products are discussed within the context of developed countries. New ventures in developing countries are typically viewed as low-cost product providers that generate technologically similar products to those produced by developed economies. However, this paper argues that some Chinese university spin-outs (USOs), although rare, have adopted a novel 'catch-up' strategy to build global products on the basis of indigenous platform technologies. This paper attempts to develop a conceptual framework to address the question: how do these specific Chinese USOs develop their innovation capabilities to build global products? In order to explore the idiosyncrasies of the specific USOs, this paper uses the multiple case studies method. The primary data sources are accessed through semi-structured interviews. In addition, archival data and other materials are used as secondary sources. The study analyses the configuration of capabilities that are needed for idiosyncratic growth, and maps them to the globalisation processes. This paper provides a strategic 'roadmap' as an explanatory guide to entrepreneurs, policy makers and investors to better understand the phenomena.
University spin-offs: entrepreneurship, growth and regional development

Andrea Caputo,David Charles,Raffaele Fiorentino

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2022.2122655

2022-09-22

Studies in Higher Education

Abstract:Over the past years, the role of universities has been faced with important changes that led to substantial attention from both researchers and policy-makers to their third mission, labelled 'a contribution to society', besides the teaching and research missions. University spin-offs (USOs or ASOs, for Academic spin-offs), emerged among the potential means for universities to pursue the third mission. Research on the creation, emergence, development and scaling up of USOs has grown significantly with contributions from multiple subject areas. This special issue contributes to the research debate by presenting novel insights that deepen and enhance our understanding of the dynamics surrounding the entrepreneurial aspects of academic spin-offs, their growth and their mutual relationship with regional development. The special issue provides rigorous qualitative, quantitative and theoretical investigations to form a research agenda which will help guide future research efforts.

education & educational research
A spill over effect of entrepreneurial orientation on technological innovativeness: an outlook of universities and research based spin offs

Veronica Scuotto,Manlio Del Giudice,Alexeis Garcia-Perez,Beatrice Orlando,Francesco Ciampi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10961-019-09760-x

2019-11-23

The Journal of Technology Transfer

Abstract:By shifting towards Romer's (Am Econ Rev 94:1002–1037, 1986) economy and so the spread of knowledge economy, universities started to adopt a collaborative approach with their entrepreneurial ecosystem. They turn out to be risk taker, autonomous, proactive, competitive, and innovative. In a nutshell, they are entrepreneurial oriented with the aim to generate new innovative ventures, known as research-based spin offs. Doubly, this has induced an improvement of technology transfer and the degree of entrepreneurship in the current knowledge economy. However there still is a paucity of studies on the spill over effect of entrepreneurial orientated universities and research-based spin off on technology transfer need to be more explored. Therefore, the article investigates the link between entrepreneurial orientation and such spill overs by offering an outlook of two universities and two research-based spin offs in the United Kingdom. The scope is to provide a deep view of technological innovativeness in a research context, entrepreneurial oriented. Our research suggests that entrepreneurial attitude has become an imperative to succeed in the context where British institutions currently operate. Entrepreneurship brings the necessary technological innovation to the university and its students, which results in better positioning of the university at national and international levels, with the subsequent impact on their ability to attract not only new students and academics but also funding to conduct their research.

management
Exploring the entrepreneurial landscape of university-industry collaboration on public university spin-off creation: A systematic literature review

Alexander Romero-Sánchez,Geovanny Perdomo-Charry,Edy Lorena Burbano-Vallejo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e27258

IF: 3.776

2024-03-04

Heliyon

Abstract:Research into the factors influencing university-industry collaboration on public university spin-offs creation has focused on management, entrepreneurship, technology and innovation. This research began with a careful systematic literature review of 4427 scientific papers published in the last ten years (2014-2023) and accessible in the prestigious Web of Science core collection. A quantitative methodology was used, complemented by the use of the visual analysis tool Posit PBC™, formerly known as R Cloud Studio. This comprehensive approach facilitated the seamless ingestion of raw data into Biblioshyni, which is a web-based platform specialised in bibliometric analysis. This review has revealed compelling trends, particularly in terms of increasing diversity, the emergence of United Kingdom as a major player, and the central role of university-industry collaboration. Our systematic review identified influential authors in the field, including the prolific contributions of scholars such as D. Radicid, S. Ropers, Y. Li and R. Owen. We also identified important research institutions, such as Utrecht University in Netherlands, Lund University in Sweden and The University of Manchester in the UK. In addition, we have shown that countries such as the United Kingdom, China and USA have made a significant contribution to the volume of publications. The results highlighted a marked increase in the phenomenon of univeristy spin-offs over the past decade, as evidenced by the exponential growth in both publication output and citation rates. This empirical revelation was underpinned by a rigorous exploration of the Web of Science database, using a carefully crafted set of keywords. Thirty-seven pivotal studies were selected for in-depth review through a sophisticated selection process that adhered to the rigorous standards of the PRISMA methodology. The aim of this review is to improve understanding and encourage deeper exploration of spin-off-based public universities through collaboration between academia and industry.
Academic spin-offs, corporate spin-outs and company internal start-ups as technology transfer approach

Gunter Festel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10961-012-9256-9

2012-04-10

The Journal of Technology Transfer

Abstract:As a rule, a technology transfer gap exists between research and development and the commercialisation of the results. This article investigates the role of new ventures for technology transfer from universities and research institutions as well as between or within companies to close this gap. Based on case studies in Germany and Switzerland, different examples of this technology transfer approach have been analysed. Academic spin-offs can help to transfer technology from universities and research institutions to industry especially if there is the need for additional funding to further develop the technology. Corporate spin-outs can be used for technology transfer between companies as an alternative to closing operations should these no longer fit into the parent organisation. Internal start-ups were identified as a new approach for company internal technology transfer from research departments to business units focused on commercial operations to overcome innovation barriers within companies.

management
Empirical Study on Spin-off Capabilities of Research Universities in China

Pang Wen,Ding Yunlong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-6711.2013.02.009

2013-01-01

Abstract:University Spin-off Company is the effective model of technology transfer and thus to promote regional economic development,university spin-off capability is directly related to the number and development performance of spin-off companies.We used S&T and school-run enterprises data of 31 "985 Project" universities in 2009 to make the factor analysis for decomposing university's spin-off capability and ranking 31 research universities,then made the correlation and regression analysis and got the following conclusions.University spin-off capabilities include capability of R&D,capability of S&T output and its application,technology trading volume and the comprehensive strength of university incubator.University research funding is closely related to its spin-off capability,basic research and applied research in university have the complementary effect on spin-off capability,the comprehensive strength of university incubator has a significant role in promoting S&T-based companies' spin-off.Finally,we proposed policy suggestions to enhance the university spin-off capability.
Universities' Core Role in the Formation of China's University Spin-off Companies

Zhou Chen,Dong Zhengying

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-9679.2009.04.021

2009-01-01

Abstract:This paper presents findings from an analysis of the determinants of the formation of universtiy spin-off companies from organizational,institutional and external aspects after reviewing amounts of research fruits.We find that universities play a core role in the development of spinoff companies under the unique administrative mechism of China,while governments and social partners should privide with their assistance in policy making and resources supporting.
Do exploration and exploitation in university research drive early-stage equity financing of university spin-offs?

Davide Hahn,Tommaso Minola,Silvio Vismara,Daniel Agyare

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-023-00862-3

IF: 7.096

2024-02-21

Small Business Economics

Abstract:An emerging theme in the entrepreneurial university (EU) literature is how universities should evolve to best reconcile their different missions, particularly research and commercialization, which often require different sets of resources. This tension is evident in the development of university spin-offs (USOs). In particular, the EU literature has generally overlooked how characteristics of university research affect USO's early-stage access to external equity. In this study, we embrace the characterization of university research offered by literature in terms of patterns, specifically, exploration and exploitation. Through the lens of the imprinting perspective, we study the effect of exploration and exploitation in university research on the early-stage equity financing of USOs on a unique dataset that covers a sample of 739 USOs from 39 Italian public universities founded from 2011 to 2019. Our results indicate that exploration (exploitation) in research has an overall positive (negative) impact on the likelihood of USOs obtaining early-stage external equity financing. Additionally, this exploratory study offers several conceptual and practical contributions to the EU literature.

economics,business,management
Patenting vs. publication: Innovation in Chinese leading universities

Qin Wang,Shanxing Gao

2010-01-01

Abstract:The emerging trend of university patenting and the potential conflict between technological commercialization and scientific publications have raised more concerns. Taking Chinese ″985 project″ universities as example, we examine the possible determinants of university patenting and the link to publications in China. We confirmed the effects of industry R & D funds on university patenting, although these effects are not significant in long run. We also found that university patents are more reactive to financial capital at university level while university publications are more responsive to the human capital. The result showed that the determinants of university patents and publications are different but compatible. Limitations and implications for future research are discussed.
From Technology Incubator to Strategic Technology Alliance——Growth Patterns on Innovation-oriented University Spin-off Company

CHEN Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-7691.2011.01.011

2011-01-01

Abstract:This paper explains the interaction mechanism between the high-tech spin-off company and its parent university in technology incubator,technology transfer and entrepreneurship incubation system.According to its strategic needs in different development stages,the spin-off company establishes strategic technology alliance(STA) with its parent university,forming a new mode of positive input – output – interactive growth that have achieved common development of both the company and the discipline of the university.Then by analyzing the case of the Tsinghua Nuctech Company,this Paper explores the law of evolution in the course of technology incubator transferring and building of STA between the university and the spin-off company.The high-tech spin-off company of university plays a significant role in developing the social function of the national innovation system.It is also pointed out that,based on input-output analysis,the university performance evaluation methods of the Ministry of Education may not only gives positive incentives to effective utilization of university resources,but also provide a new opportunity for Chinese universities to promote university spin-off companies.
An individual-level assessment of the relationship between spin-off activities and research performance in universities

Giovanni Abramo,Ciriaco Andrea D'Angelo,Marco Ferretti,Adele Parmentola

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1810.13382

2018-10-31

Digital Libraries

Abstract:One of the most problematic aspects in the creation of spin-offs by university personnel concerns the relationship between entrepreneurial activity and research activity by researcher-entrepreneurs. The literature has expressed varying and opposing views as to the nature of the relationship but very little has been produced to empirically legitimate one position or another. The present work proposes to address this shortcoming by exploring the relationship existing between academic spin-off generation and the research performance of enterprise founders. The study investigates whether, and to what extent, scientific performance by academic entrepreneurs is different than that of their colleagues, and if the involvement in entrepreneurial activity has an influence on the individual's research activity. The research questions are answered by considering all spin-offs generated by Italian universities over the period 2001-2008 and evaluating, through a bibliometric approach, the scientific performance of founders relative to that of their colleagues who carry out research in the same field. The data show better scientific performance by the researcher-entrepreneurs than that of their colleagues and in addition, although there are some variations across fields, the creation of a spin-off does not seem, on average, to have negative effects on the scientific performance of the founders.
Academic spin-off activities and research performance: the mediating role of research collaboration

Huan Li,Xi Yang,Xinlan Cai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10961-021-09869-y

2021-07-02

The Journal of Technology Transfer

Abstract:Studies on the effect of entrepreneurial activities on scientists' subsequent research performance have reported mixed findings. Given the misalignment between spin-off involvement and research activity, our study aims to add to the literature on academic entrepreneurship by examining this effect in a new context and testing the mediating role of research collaboration. We hypothesize that spin-off involvement fosters research collaboration between entrepreneurs and external researchers, which in turn is conducive to research performance. The empirical exercise is based on a sample of 945 scientists at 11 leading material sciences faculties in China, focusing on their spin-off involvement from 2012 to 2014 and their publication records in the following 5-year period. We find that spin-off involvement has a positive effect on individual scientists' subsequent research excellence but does not significantly increase their research productivity. Our findings also confirm the mediating role of research collaboration (both academic–corporate and domestic cross-institutional) in the association between spin-off involvement and research performance.

management
Why University Academic Commercialization Will Be Revisiting In China?

Sun Linbo,Chen Jin

2016-01-01

Abstract:In china, university technology in facilitating local economic development, Make up for Industry R&D capabilities, university gain the financial benefits, So the Chinese university have a strong propensity to transfer the technological and established their own firms. The paper evaluates the efficiency of Chinese university research commercialization by decomposing the commercialization process into the two connecting sub-processes, academic innovation and academic commercialization Based on the dataset of 2009-2014 commercial activities of 64 Chinese key universities, the technical efficiency by using network DEA. The results indicates that academic commercial efficiency is better than academic innovation efficiency and commercialization capacity plays a more important role in the overall process. Finally, some managerial and policy implications for improving research commercialization are suggested.
The effectiveness of university knowledge spillovers: Performance differences between university spinoffs and corporate spinoffs

Karl Wennberg,Johan Wiklund,Mike Wright

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2011.05.014

IF: 7.2

2011-10-01

Research Policy

Abstract:While much prior research has focused upon how the Technology Transfer Offices (TTOs) and other contextual characteristics shape the level of university spinoffs (USO), there is little research on entrepreneurial potential among individual academics, and to the best of our knowledge, no comparative studies with other types of spinoffs exist to date. In this paper we focus on an important but neglected aspect of knowledge transfer from academic research involving the indirect flow to entrepreneurship by individuals with a university education background who become involved in new venture creation by means of corporate spinoffs (CSO) after gaining industrial experience, rather than leaving university employment to found a new venture as an academic spinoff. We argue that the commercial knowledge gained by industry experience is potentially more valuable for entrepreneurial performance compared to the academic knowledge gained by additional research experience at a university. This leads us to posit that the average performance of CSOs will be higher than comparable USOs, but the gains from founder‘s prior experiences will be relatively higher among USOs whose founders lack the corporate context. We investigate these propositions in a comparative study tracking the complete population of USOs and CSOs among the Swedish knowledge-intensive sectors between 1994 and 2002.

management
Have Chinese Universities Embraced Their Third Mission? New Insight from a Business Perspective.

Yuandi Wang,Jiashun Huang,Yantai Chen,Xiongfeng Pan,Jin Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-013-1055-z

IF: 3.801

2013-01-01

Scientometrics

Abstract:Have Chinese universities, after enormous investment over the past decade, embraced the university’s third mission—contributing to industrial and technological progress? The literature has not sufficiently addressed this question. This study intends to advance understanding of this issue by empirically addressing this question from a business perspective in a bold and unconventional way. Unlike prior studies that simply used contingent and institutional factors to describe the link between Chinese universities and industrial firms by measuring such aspects as patent licensing, co-patenting, and co-authoring, our work goes further and applies longitudinal analysis to examine the ways firms access university-level knowledge and the impact of such knowledge on firm innovation outputs. We propose that if Chinese universities embraced their third mission, then we would observe a positive effect of university–industry collaborations on firms’ subsequent innovation outputs. Empirical results based on a sample of the top 100 Chinese electronic firms in terms of output value support our hypothesis. Specifically, university patent licensing and co-patenting between universities and firms was found to positively affect firm innovation outputs. Moreover, we found that geographical distance and collaboration dominance moderate the co-patenting–innovation output relationship.

University spin-offs: Opportunity or challenge?

Facilitators of formation of spin-offs in university-industry collaboration

Barriers to entrepreneurial growth: an empirical study on university spin‐offs in China

A Literature Review on the University Spin-off Company

University spin-offs: the past, the present, and the future

Research on the Relationship of Institutional Innovation, Organizational Learning and Synergistic Effect: an Empirical Study of Chineses University Spin-Offs

Building Global Products and Competing in Innovation: the Role of Chinese University Spin-Outs and Required Innovation Capabilities

University spin-offs: entrepreneurship, growth and regional development

A spill over effect of entrepreneurial orientation on technological innovativeness: an outlook of universities and research based spin offs

Exploring the entrepreneurial landscape of university-industry collaboration on public university spin-off creation: A systematic literature review

Academic spin-offs, corporate spin-outs and company internal start-ups as technology transfer approach

Empirical Study on Spin-off Capabilities of Research Universities in China

Universities' Core Role in the Formation of China's University Spin-off Companies

Do exploration and exploitation in university research drive early-stage equity financing of university spin-offs?

Patenting vs. publication: Innovation in Chinese leading universities

From Technology Incubator to Strategic Technology Alliance——Growth Patterns on Innovation-oriented University Spin-off Company

An individual-level assessment of the relationship between spin-off activities and research performance in universities

Academic spin-off activities and research performance: the mediating role of research collaboration

Why University Academic Commercialization Will Be Revisiting In China?

The effectiveness of university knowledge spillovers: Performance differences between university spinoffs and corporate spinoffs

Have Chinese Universities Embraced Their Third Mission? New Insight from a Business Perspective.