Abstract:In this paper, we develop an efficient mutual information based similarity metric for 3D medical image registration. The efficiency of the metric lies in the computation of mutual information, which uses modified algorithms for calculating entropy and joint entropy. We implemented the newly developed Efficient Entropy Mutual Information (EEMI) metric in SimpleITK, which is an open source image registration and segmentation toolkit. We designed 24 medical image registration frameworks using four similarity metrics, namely Mean Squares (MS), Joint Histogram Mutual Information (JHMI), Mattes Mutual Information (MattesMI) and our proposed EEMI, and six optimizers namely, Gradient Descent (GD), Conjugate Geadient Line Search (CGLS), 1+1 Evolutionary, Powell, Nelder-Mead (Amoeba) and Limited Memory Broyden Fletcher Goldfarb Shannon (LBFGS2). Using these frameworks, we performed elaborate comparative evaluation and analysis of EEMI in terms of registration accuracy and computation time. We used four different medical image data sets for our experiments. Data consisted of intra-modal and inter-modal image pairs of the brain and thorax obtained from different medical institutions as well as publicly available databases. Registration results prove the superiority and consistency of performance of EEMI compared to MS and JHMI. When compared with the benchmark MattesMI metric, performance of EEMI is on a par with respect to Dice score, Jaccard score and Hausdorff distance. With respect to computation time, EEMI is faster with GD, CGLS and Amoeba optimizers with 61.29%, 42.67% and 10.92% gain in computation times respectively. Among the other three optimizers, EEMI is more consistent with Powell's optimizer. Mean, median and STD of TRE values of EEMI with Powell's optimizer are respectively 67.42%, 65.84% and 74.63% less than that of MattesMI. Hausdorff distance of EEMI is 47.47% less than MattesMI, with Powell's optimizer.

Adaptive Exponential Weighted Mutual Information As a Similarity Measure for Medical Image Registration

Regional Weighted Mutual Information For Multimodal Rigid Registration

Non-rigid Registration of Biomedical Image for Radiotherapy Based on Adaptive Feature Density Flow

Local Registration of Medical Images Using Feature Point and Intensity Information

Medical Image Elastic Registration Based on Contour and Feature Points

An Improved Medical Image Registration Algorithm Based on Mutual Information

Multi-modality Medical Image Registration Using High Dimension Mutual Information

Computation of Mutual Information in Medical Image Registration Based on Mutual Information

Multi-modal Medical Image Registration Based on Adaptive Combination of Intensity and Gradient Field Mutual Information

Similarity Metric in Medical Image Registration

Research on Multi-Modality Medical Image Registration Based on Mutual Information

Multi-Modal Image Registration Based on Multi-Feature Mutual Information

An efficient similarity metric for 3D medical image registration

Self-similarity weighted mutual information: A new nonrigid image registration metric

A Hybrid Method for Medical Image Registration Based on Multi-resolution Analysis

Robust computation of mutual information using spatially adaptive meshes

Logarithmic Fuzzy Entropy Function for Similarity Measurement in Multimodal Medical Images Registration.

Mutual Information Medical Image Registration Based on Firefly Algorithm

Non-Rigid Medical Image Registration with Joint Histogram Estimation Based on Mutual Information

[A Method for the Medical Image Registration Based on the Statistics Samples Averaging Distribution Theory].

Unifying Energy Minimization And Mutual Information Maximization For Robust 2d/3d Registration Of X-Ray And Ct Images