Abstract:Two-frequency phase-shifting phase unwrapping and Gray-coded-based phase unwrapping are two typical temporal phase unwrapping methods to recover discontinuous or spatially isolated surfaces in fringe projection profilometry (FPP). But in dynamic measurement, environmental noise, required number of patterns and inter-frame motion affect the performance of these two methods on measuring anti-noise ability, efficiency and robustness in varying degrees. So, it is a challenge to quantitatively compare these methods' abilities and determine the optimum one with appropriate system parameters and under a certain condition. In this paper, a detailed comparative study is conducted for the two-frequency phase-shifting method including hierarchical, number-theoretical and heterodyne approaches and the Gray-coded-based method including traditional Gray code approach, complementary Gray code approach and Gray code approach with tripartite phase unwrapping (Tri-PU). First, the principles of six approaches are reviewed; then, their anti-noise ability was quantitatively compared based on the proposed noise model; next, theoretical comparison of measuring efficiency, comparative review of improved methods and recommendation on usage are given to boost their efficiency; finally, motion-induced error model in phase unwrapping was presented to determine the appropriate system parameters in dynamic measurement. Theoretical analysis, numerical simulation and experimental results are consistent and demonstrate that (i) Gray-coded-based method has better anti-noise ability than two-frequency phase-shifting method; (ii) two-frequency phase-shifting method is more efficient than traditional Gray-coded-based method when the number of encoding fringe periods exceeds 8; (iii) hierarchical approach and Gray-coded approach with Tri-PU have best performance to resist motion-induced error in their respective types of methods. Comparative results can give a helpful guidance to choose the "best" approach in different application scenes and quantitatively determine the projected fringe periods and imaging or projecting speed in dynamic measurement for FPP.

A Robust Phase Difference Instantaneous Frequency Measure Method Based on Unwrap

A Reliable Phase Unwrapping Algorithm Based on the Local Fitting Plane and Quality Map

Fast Phase-unwrapping Algorithms Used for Structural-light Measurement

Adaptive Phase Unwrapping Method Based on Geometric Constraint

A Phase Unwrapping Algorithm Based on Periodicity Extension

Quality Weight Based Discrete Cosine Transform Phase Unwrapping Algorithm in Optical Interferogram Processing

A Hybrid Phase-Unwrapping Method For Optical Interferometry Based On New Parameter Map And Local Plane Approximation

Discussion about the DCT/FFT Phase-Unwrapping Algorithm for Interferometric Applications

Closed-form, robust and accurate multi-frequency phase unwrapping: frequency design and algorithm

Practical Phase Unwrapping of Interferometric Fringes Based on Unscented Kalman Filter Technique.

Towards a Novel Phase Unwrapping Model for Three Dimensional Measurement

A Fast Phase Unwrapping Method Based on Region-Division

Using temporal phase unwrapping mask for shape measurement

An Efficient Implementation of a Robust Phase-Unwrapping Algorithm

Comparative study of phase unwrapping algorithms based on solving the Poisson equation

Precise and Fast Phase Wraps Reduction in Fringe Projection Profilometry

A New Method Using Orthogonal Two-Frequency Grating in Online 3d Measurement

Phase Unwrapping Method Based on Jumping Order Estimation

Three-dimensional measurements based on multivariate gray code phase encoding

Application research of Fourier-transform-based deterministic phase-unwrapping algorithm

Two-frequency phase-shifting method vs. Gray-coded-based method in dynamic fringe projection profilometry: A comparative review