Soil respiration and the measurement of microbial biomass C by the fumigation technique in fresh and in air-dried soil
Shen Shan-Min,P.C. Brookes,D.S. Jenkinson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-0717(87)90075-7
IF: 8.546
1987-01-01
Soil Biology and Biochemistry
Abstract:There is controversy about the choice of control in measuring soil microbial biomass by the fumigation-incubation method. As originally proposed, biomass C is calculated from the difference between the CO2 evolved by fumigated soil during a 10-day incubation, less a “control”, taken to be the CO2 evolved by unfumigated soil, also over a 10-day period. The need for a control arises because there is strong evidence that not all the CO2 evolved by the fumigated soil comes from the decomposition of organisms killed by the fumigant. Four methods of calculating soil microbial biomass C, based on different controls, were compared on moist soils, on the same soils immediately after they had been air dried and rewetted and on the rewetted air-dried soils after a 10-day incubation.The methods for calculating biomass C (B1, B2 etc.) were: B1 = [(CO2-C evolved by fumigated soil, 0–10 days) -(CO2-C evolved by unfumigated soil, 0–10 days)]/0.45; B2 = [(CO2-C evolved by fumigated soil, 0–10 days) − (CO2-C evolved by unfumigated soil, 10–20 days)]/0.45; B3 = [(CO2-C evolved by fumigated soil, 0–10 days)-(CO2-C evolved by fumigated soil, 10–20 days)]/0.45 and B4 = [CO2-C evolved by fumigated soil, 0–10 days]/0.45.On soils that had been incubated moist for some time, it mattered relatively little whether biomass C was calculated as B1, B2 or B3; calculation B4 gave much larger values. On soils that had been air dried, remoistened but not incubated, the only internally consistent values were those calculated as B1 which indicated that biomass decreased when soils were dried. Methods B2, B3 and B4 gave unacceptable results, in that they all indicated that biomass increased when soils were dried. Method B4 also gave unacceptable results on soils that had been air-dried, remoistened and incubated, in that it indicated a decrease in biomass when air-dried remoistened soils were incubated. Evidence is assembled for a special type of respiration in soil, termed “basal respiration” in which respiration is limited by the rate at which substrate is released from soil organic matter, rather than by the maximum specific growth rate of the soil population, as happens when fresh substrate decomposes in soil.Air drying at 25°C decreased soil microbial biomass, but this decrease was much less marked in soil dried at 10°C.
soil science