Abstract:This article explores the exam-oriented, ritualistic, and exemplary Chinese education system through a double-layered historical and ethnographic analysis. Firstly, I examine three aspects of the educational governing complex—exemplarity, ritual, and examination. Historically, education has been a key locus to craft exemplary subjects through rituals and imitation of models, and this is reinforced by exams to justify social hierarchy. The production of subjectivities in Chinese schools has never been too far removed from these aspects of exemplarity, ritual, and examination. Secondly, I offer an account of the contested “quality curriculum reform” in rural China. While the reform aims to foster creativity and criticizes the overemphasis on exams, classroom rituals, and exemplary icons, its implementation renormalizes the tripartite governing paradigm and produces a contradictory mix of subjectifying discourses in everyday school lives. The study shows that contemporary pedagogic discourse is still rooted in traditional elements, even if the reform aims to do away with, however partially, these elements. In the multi-layered field of Chinese education, pedagogical actors both abide by and react against the historical and contemporary visions of educational governing with hybrid subjectivities. The study sheds light on why China’s curriculum reform is far from an easy task.

From Nominal Specification to Substantive Efficiency:Our Experience in Deliberation of Curriculum Policy and Its Reflection

Several Reflections on Curriculum Reform

Curriculum Policy Process:Perspective of Policy Research

From Policy in Text to Policy in Action: Enactment and Evolution of Curriculum Policy in Practice

The Combination of Fairness and Science in the Reform of College Entrance Examination

The Liberation of New Curriculum Policy Evaluation in China

The Policy Making of Curriculum Reform of International Basic Education

On the Purport of Educational Policy Research:Its Transition and Development in China

The Basic Traits of Progress in Curriculum Reform in Developed Countries and Its Enlightenment-In the Perspective of Curriculum Policy Design

Value Selection of China's Education Policy in the Future

The seeming ‘round trip’ of learner-centred education: a ‘best practice’ derived from China’s New Curriculum Reform?

A Study on the Reform and Improvement of Decision-Making Mechanisms in the University——Analysis Based on the Perspective of Deliberative Democracy

THE 'GAP' BETWEEN POLICY INTENT AND POLICY EFFECT: AN EXPLORATION OF THE INTERPRETATIONS OF SCHOOL PRINCIPALS IN CHINA

Political development in China: duet-variation of theory and practice

Transcending the Nature of Refinement: The Policy Development on Liberal Arts Education in China

Educational discipline, ritual governing, and Chinese exemplary society: Why China’s curriculum reform remains a difficult task

Coordination Between Efficiency and Fairness:from Ideas to Practice

Exploring Deliberative Policy Analysis in an Authoritarian Country

Making a Competitive Selection or a Compromise?—An Explanatory Framework and a Consensus-centered Model in the Process of Policymaking in China's Economic Transition

The Democratization of Public Policy Making with Chinese Characteristic:Formulation of the China's 12th Five-Year Plan

Moral Education Curriculum Reform for China’s Elementary and Middle Schools in the Twenty-First Century: Past Progress and Future Prospects