Analysis of Terrain Induced Impact on Takin (budorcas Taxicolor) Home Range Estimation: an Example from Fixed Kernel Estimator and Minimum Convex Polygon

William Mcshea
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16829/j.slxb.2012.02.004
2012-01-01
Abstract:Knowledge of the home range of wildlife is the basis of effective conservation and management.We studied takin(Budorcas taxicolor tibetana) home range in spring with two widely applied methods using GIS related software,where we compared differences between the home range estimates with and without terrain information.All four takin(2♀2♂) were fixed with GPS radio collars and the data were obtained in the spring of 2007 and of 2008.The results showed home range size derived with terrain information(FKE95%=7.50±2.27,MCP=7.01±1.99) was significantly larger than that derived without topographic information(FKE95%=5.94±1.54,t=3.31,df=3,P=0.045,MCP=5.47±1.52,df=3,t=3.34,P=0.041).The difference between estimates based on 95% Fixed kernel home range and Minimum convex polygon home range were not significant regardless of including terrain information(t=0.612,df=3,P=0.584) or not(t=0.718,df=3,P=0.524).However,we also found significant differences of home range size between individuals(One way ANOVA,df=3,F=7.226,P=0.001).The post hoc test between individuals found significant differences between M1 and F1(P=0.001),M1 and F2(P=0.031),M1 and M2(P=0.02),F1 and F2(P=0.044),whereas no significant difference was detected between M2 and F2(P=0.221),M2 and F1(P=0.598).We also tested the difference of the two methods on the results of spatial overlap between individuals,but no significant difference was detected.Researchers should select appropriate smooth parameters(h)/bandwidth,because different bandwidth may derive different conclusions of the degree of home range overlap,or even contradictory results.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?