Abstract:Regression modeling of biomass estimates from an airborne, multiple return lidar system using regional biomass allometric equations differs significantly from those using national scale Jenkins allometric equations with respect to the amount of variation explained, variables selected and variables of importance. Our discrete return lidar data were collected in September 2007 at 121 plots in a conifer dominated forest site in the Sierra Nevada mountains that include a full range of forest density. We regressed field plot-level estimates of biomass derived from field data and two different allometric equations with a range of lidar metrics. We compared regression performance across eight models: (1) point clouds alone, (2) point clouds with an empirical relationship between DBH and height (i.e., volume), (3) individual tree-level metrics, and (4) all data combined, and across two allometric equations - (A) Forest Inventory Analysis (FIA), and (B) Jenkins. In lower biomass plots, the reference above ground biomass (AGB) estimates from regional allometric equations and Jenkins equations were closely related; in plots with large biomass they were different. This finding suggests that published equations from large biomass plots are either not readily available or less represented in national scale allometric equation compiling. Models using reference AGBs calculated from regional allometric equations performed much better than those using reference AGBs calculated from Jenkins allometric equations. In these cases adjusted R-2 improvement ranged from 0.07 to 0.11. The regression model that used regional allometric equations with lidar metrics and individual tree data provided the best overall R-2 (0.79) with lowest RMSE suggesting that in most conditions regional biomass equations should be preferred over national equations. The inclusion of volumetric metrics shows that lidar variables are more sensitive to the reference AGBs calculated from regional allometric equations, and care should be taken when substituting regional equations using national scale compiled allometric equations in regional biomass studies. In addition, consistent with previous studies, the mean height of individual trees identified was chosen by both models with both reference AGBs calculated from regional allometric equations and those calculated from Jenkins equations, supporting the need to identify individual trees for biomass prediction. Based on these results, we conclude that the selection of allometric equations can influence the capacity of lidar data to estimate biomass significantly, and a careful selection of allometric equations is required for regional lidar biomass studies. (c) 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Forest Biomass Allometry in Global Land Surface Models

Allometric growth and allocation in forests: a perspective from FLUXNET

Benchmarking Carbon Fluxes of the Isimip2a Biome Models

Scaling Relationships Between Leaf Mass and Total Plant Mass Across Chinese Forests

Benchmarking simulations of forest regrowth across Europe

Potential knowledge gain in large-scale simulations of forest carbon fluxes from remotely sensed biomass and height

Comparison of forest above-ground biomass from dynamic global vegetation models with spatially explicit remotely sensed observation-based estimates

Relationships among the Stem, Aboveground and Total Biomass Across Chinese Forests

Evaluating changes of biomass in global vegetation models: the role of turnover fluctuations and ENSO events

A critique of general allometry-inspired models for estimating forest carbon density from airborne LiDAR

The potential benefit of using forest biomass data in addition to carbon and water flux measurements to constrain ecosystem model parameters: case studies at two temperate forest sites

Distribution of Biomass Dynamics in Relation to Tree Size in Forests Across the World

Accuracy, realism and general applicability of European forest models

Variations of Carbon Allocation and Turnover Time Across Tropical Forests

Allometric equations for integrating remote sensing imagery into forest monitoring programmes

New allometric models for the USA create a step-change in forest carbon estimation, modeling, and mapping

Comparison among allometric models for tree biomass estimation using non-destructive trees’ data

Improved allometric models to estimate the aboveground biomass of tropical trees

A Generic Pixel-to-point Comparison for Simulated Large-Scale Ecosystem Properties and Ground-Based Observations: an Example from the Amazon Region

Global Patterns of Ecosystem Carbon Flux in Forests: A Biometric Data‐based Synthesis

Allometric equation choice impacts lidar-based forest biomass estimates: A case study from the Sierra National Forest, CA