Abstract:PurposeMany industrial fields count, these days, on data collection as a backup source for machinery condition monitoring to increase their equipment safety, reduce maintenance costs, avoid eventual damages and minimize operational downtime. In electromechanical systems, generated signals such as vibrations, acoustics, electrical current, and thermal images are considered a sensitive and a loaded source of information about the equipment’s health condition. Despite its acquisition, these data had shown a direct dependence to their nature and need further steps to be adequately analyzed and ready to be used as a decision making reliable support. Hence, signal processing methods are usually used to identify the current state of the system. However, these techniques had shown some limitations, especially for varying rotating speed, noisy environment where filtering is required or when defects are in their early stages. These constrains led to the research community to consider further developed methods to deal with such issues.MethodsFeature extraction based on the maximal overlap discrete wavelet packet transform MODWPT is known for its ability to decompose the raw signal into several intrinsic ones on which features will be extracted. That is why it is employed as a first expertise step on both vibration and acoustic signals. Machine learning techniques (KNN, DT, ET, RF, and SVM) are then implemented to diagnose and differentiate between different types of faults in time-varying rotational speed machines and to compare the outcomes of vibration and acoustic signals in this matter.ResultsThe obtained results demonstrated the superiority of vibration signal’s outcome over acoustic signal. Machine learning classifiers had yielded higher stability (STD = 0) and accuracy (100%) for ET and RF when fed with vibration signal’s features. However, an STD of 0.005976 and an accuracy of 99.9433% were the best obtained results from SVM when fed with acoustic signal’s features.ConclusionMachine learning methods had proven their efficiency in time-varying machines fault diagnosis when taking vibration and acoustic signals extracted features as inputs. However, the use of vibration signal’s features demonstrated a higher robustness and a remarkable superiority.

Review of Signal Processing Methods in Fault Diagnosis for Machinery Using Time-frequency Analysis

Review of Signal Processing Methods in Fault Diagnosis for Machinery

Recent Advances in Time–frequency Analysis Methods for Machinery Fault Diagnosis: A Review with Application Examples

Signal Processing Methods in Fault Diagnosis of Machinery——Analyses in Frequency Doman

Application of adaptive time frequency analysis to fault diagnosis of machinery: A review

Overview of Time-Frequency Analysis Techniques in Vibration Signals of Rotating Machinery

Review of spectrum analysis in fault diagnosis for mechanical equipment

Developments of new feature extraction methods in machinery fault diagnosis

Fault Diagnosis Based on Multi-channel Vibration Signal for Port Machine Trolley Wheel Bearings

Review of Signal Decomposition Theory and Its Applications in Machine Fault Diagnosis

Fault Diagnosis of Rolling Bearing Based on Wavelet Packet and Fourier Analysis

Machinery Diagnosis Based on Wavelet Packets

A vibration analysis method based on hybrid techniques and its application to rotating machinery

Adaptive Mode Decomposition Methods and Their Applications in Signal Analysis for Machinery Fault Diagnosis: A Review With Examples

SURVEY OF THE APPLICATION OF CYCLOSTATIONARY SIGNAL PROCESSING IN MACHINERY FAULT DIAGNOSIS

Research of high-resolution vibration signal detection technique and application to mechanical fault diagnosis

Fault Diagnosis of Gears Based on Time-Wavelet Energy Spectrum

Synchrosqueezing extracting transform and its application in bearing fault diagnosis under non-stationary conditions

A Time-Frequency Spectral Amplitude Modulation Method and Its Applications in Rolling Bearing Fault Diagnosis

Faults’ Diagnosis of Time-Varying Rotational Speed Machinery Based on Vibration and Acoustic Signals Features Extraction, and Machine Learning Methods

Machinery Fault Signal Reconstruction Using Time-Frequency Manifold