Fanwort in Eastern China: an Invasive Aquatic Plant and Potential Ecological Consequences
XY Zhang,Y Zhong,JK Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1579/0044-7447-32.2.158
IF: 6.94
2003-01-01
AMBIO
Abstract:Fanwort (Cabomba caroliniana) is a freshwater perennial plant with short rhizomes and submerged (sometimes floating) leaves, native to the subtropicaltemperate regions of northeastern and southeastern America. The species occurs from Texas to Florida, northward to Massachusetts, and westward to Kansas (1– 3). Fanwort generally grows in ponds, lakes and streams with 1–3 m of water. An attractive and inexpensive aquarium plant, fanwort has long been grown commercially, for sale in pet stores in the US, Europe, and other parts of the world (4). In Asia, fanwort was first recorded in Japan as a species which had escaped from aquarium cultivation (5). Its common name in Kanji is also accepted and used in China. In 1993, fanwort was found for the first time in a river at the Mozhizhen Township of Ningbo, Zhejiang Province, China (6). Since then, a number of specimens of fanwort have been collected from a relatively wide range of its distribution. On the basis of herbarium specimens and comparative studies, Ding (7) and Wan et al. (8) published 2 taxonomic articles with morphological description, citing fanwort as a naturalized species in eastern China (7, 8). The articles documented fanwort invasions in many cities, including Ningbo, Shaoxing, Yuyao, Hangzhou, Jiaxing, and Huzhou of Zhejiang Province, and Suzhou and Changshu of Jiangsu Province, as well as Qingpu County, Shanghai (Fig. 1). However, the cause and process of the invasion was not discussed. Recently, we revisited the main fanwort distribution regions in eastern China and invited the authors of 2 papers (7, 8) to join our team. Prior to site-by-site fieldwork, we sequenced the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) regions of nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA), which is a standard molecular marker for detecting interor infraspecific variation, from a sample of fanwort collected from Suzhou, Jiangsu Province. A phylogenetic analysis of the family Cabombaceae and related groups (waterlilies) was then undertaken based on our sequence and the sequences gathered from GenBank. The molecular evidence confirms that the fanwort in China is an invasive species (Zhang et al., in prep.). Our results show a series of events leading to invasive fanwort in eastern China. First, fanwort invaded various waterbodies and became the dominant species in some aquatic communities, with a variety of other species (Table 1). The structure and functions of these communities could be affected by the rapid spread of fanwort, because it is an extremely persistent and competitive species. Second, invasive fanwort has become a problem for human activities in some areas. For example, it is now found in the parks of famous scenic spots such as Donghu Lake, Shaoxing, Zhejiang, and restricts human recreational activities. Human activities may even accelerate the spread of fanwort. Third, although water quality/ water transparency is usually a limiting factor for the growth of fanwort, the species can adapt to new environments in a very short time. In fact, water qualities in the sites we investigated varied, but fanwort growth was shown to be fair to good and very good, indicating strong adaptation. Both invasive species and aquatic weeds have begun to attract the attention of scientists, government agencies, and the general public due to their environmental impact worldwide (9, 10). Invasive aquatic weeds are a serious threat to the health of lakes, rivers, and streams. Common effects include changes to local biodiversity; competion with useful species for available nutrients, light, and space; reduction of oxygen levels; increases in water loss due to evapotranspiration; and restriction of navigation and recreational activities, etc. In China, a number of invasive species have become highly detrimental aquatic weeds, during the 20 century (11, 12). Two obvious examples are alligator alternanthera (Alternanthera philoxeroides), an aggressive South American plant that flourishes both in water and on land, which was introduced as a forage grass; and common water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes), a free-floating perennial aquatic plant introduced from the Amazon River basin, South America, as a forage and water-purifying plant. Their detrimental effects on rivers, wetlands, and irrigated agriculture in China have now been documented, but no simple approach has been established for their effective control. Fanwort has a different ecological niche than other aquatic weeds such as alligator alternanthera and common water hyaFigure 1. Distribution of invasive fanwort in eastern China from herbarium specimens (open triangles) and our field investigations (solid triangles).