Abstract:This paper reviews selected post–Global Financial Crisis theoretical and empirical contributions on capital controls and identifies three theoretical motives for the use of capital controls: pecuniary externalities in models of financial crises, aggregate demand externalities in New Keynesian models of the business cycle, and terms of trade manipulation in open-economy models with pricing power. Pecuniary and demand externalities offer the most compelling case for the adoption of capital controls, but macroprudential policy can also address the same distortions. So capital controls generally are not the only instrument that can do the job. If evaluated through the lenses of the new theories, the empirical evidence reviewed suggests that capital controls can have the intended effects, even though the extant literature is inconclusive as to whether the effects documented amount to a net gain or loss in welfare terms. Terms of trade manipulation also provides a clear-cut theoretical case for the use of capital controls, but this motive is less compelling because of the spillover and coordination issues inherent in the use of control on capital flows for this purpose. Perhaps not surprisingly, only a handful of countries have used capital controls in a countercyclical manner, while many adopted macroprudential policies. This suggests that capital control policy might entail additional costs other than increased financing costs, such as signaling the bad quality of future policies, leakages, and spillovers.

Capital Account Opening and the Effectiveness of Capital Controls in Brazil since the 1990s

Capital Account Opening and the Effectiveness of Capital Controls in Columbia

BANK PRIVATIZATION IN MEXICO:BACKGROUND, PROCEDURES AND RESULTS

Monetary policy through the risk-taking channel: Evidence from an emerging market

Capital Market Liberalization: Optimal Tradeoff and Bargaining Delay

Achieving Capital Account Convertibility in China1

Radicalism or Gradualism?:Study Based on Brazil's 20-year Transformation Experience

The Sequence of the Capital Account Liberalization——Policy Implications for China

Capital Controls and Foreign Currency Denomination

Capital controls and the global financial cycle

Brazil, BITs and FDI: A Synthetic Control Approach

Dynamic treatment effect of capital controls on macroeconomic and financial stability in emerging market economies

Long-term Financing: Exploring the Recent Advances in the Brazilian Bond Market

Banking unconditionally: the political economy of Chinese finance in Latin America

A New Approach to Capital Control for Emerging Market Economies

The impact of capital Inflow's features on the effectiveness of capital controls - Evidence from multinational data

A study of the time-varying impact of capital account liberalization on monetary policy rules in the open economy: Evidence from China

The politics of capital mobility in dollarized economies: comparing Ecuador and El Salvador

Capital Controls: A Survey of the New Literature

Capital inflow liberalization and bank credit risk

Capital Flows and Financial Stability: the Mexican Experience