Comparison of Modified Kugel and Lichtenstein repair in adult hernias
MU Jia-sheng,LIU Ying-bin,LU Jian-hua,GU Jun,DONG Ping,ZHAO Ming-ning,HAO Yuan,WU Xiang-song,LI Mao-lan,TAN Zhu-jun,DONG Qian
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/cma.j.issn.1674-392X.2013.05.024
2013-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the efficacy of Modified Kugel( M-K) repair and Lichtenstein repair in the prospective clinical study. Methods A total of 218 cases of adult patients with inguinal hernia from August 2010 to April 2012 in the Xinhua Hospital Affilated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine were enrolled and randomized to receive treatments of Lichtenstein( control group) and M-K repair( obsevation group). The mean operation time,postoperative hospitalization stau,cost of hospitalization and complication were assessed. Results No differences were observed in the mean operation time,length of postoperative hospitalization stay,the recovering time,hematoma of scotum,local seroma,spermatic edmma,and cardiovascular cerebrovascular accident rate( t = 1. 262,0. 849,1. 282,χ2= 1. 005,0. 338,0. 338,0. 338,P all < 0. 05). Local foreign body sensation and cost of hospitalization in control group were less than those in obsevation group( χ2= 4. 670,14. 236,P all < 0. 05). Conclusion The M-K repair is a reliable tension-free operation with rapid recovery,especially for those patients with high risk of recurrence.