A Strong Schema Can Interfere with Learning: The Case of Children’s Typical Addition Schema
Nicole M. McNeil,Martha W. Alibali
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315782379-149
2019-04-24
Abstract:This study investigated whether children’s schema for typical addition interferes with their ability to learn about mathematical equivalence. In a pretest, elementary school children (1) solved a set of math equivalence problems (e.g., 3 + 4 + 5 = 3 + _), (2) reconstructed equivalence problems after viewing them briefly, and (3) provided definitions of the equal sign. Children were categorized according to the number of measures (out of 3) on which they exhibited the typical addition schema. Children then received one of four interventions that presented new information about equivalence problems. Finally, children completed a posttest similar to the pretest. From pretest to posttest, children who exhibited the addition schema on all three measures were the least likely to change their strategy for solving the problems, followed by children who exhibited the schema on two or one of the measures. All of the children who did not exhibit the schema on any of the three measures changed. It is important to note that all children used incorrect strategies at pretest, so it was the addition schema in particular that was associated with change resistance. Thus, a strong schema can interfere with learning. Furthermore, children’s addition schema may put them at risk for difficulties in learning higher-level mathematics. Some behaviors and ideas are particularly difficult for individuals to acquire, even after numerous attempts have been made by the individuals to learn them or by instructors to teach them. The woman’s knowledge about addition may be organized into a strong schema that interferes with her memorizing of the addition facts, and the father’s knowledge about his first language may be organized into a strong schema that interferes with his learning of the second language. The typical addition schema is adaptive because children need to use their knowledge of addition to learn other math concepts, such as multiplication and division. Children exhibited the typical addition schema in their action procedures, perceptual encodings and conceptual knowledge. Specifically, findings suggest that a strong typical addition schema carries a heavy price and may put children at risk for difficulties in later years when algebraic equations become the focus of mathematics instruction.