Women as Insurance Assets in Traditional Societies: A study of brideprices during 18-19 century China
Zhiwu Chen,Shijun He,Zhan Lin,Kaixiang Peng,Denggao Long,Weipeng Yuan,Debin Ma,Kang Wang,Yongwei Chen,Ruixue Jia,Xuemei Peng,Shixia Qu,Shujuan Liu,Wei Xu,Xiaobin Zheng,Hua Zhang,Tao Gui,Bofang Zhou,Shiting Zhu,Xinliu Yang,Shasha Li,Hao Jia,Liuyang Zhao,Yingmeng Jian,Juan Wang,He Xu,Guangwei Pan,Xiaobing Bao,Zhengliang Gao,Aolin Li,Jingzhu Li,Hui Liu,Lili Mi,Peng Shi,Xiaojin Wan,Zaihong Wang,Zhiqian Xie,Kang Zhang,Lingli Zhang
2015-01-01
Abstract:Before modern financial markets emerged, agrarian societies relied on non-financial means to mitigate risks. Women became an apparatus of insurance—they were traded for other resources when the survival of a family was under threat. This happened on different continents in places with little or no connections with each other. To examine how women were used in traditional societies as an insurance tool, this paper collected data on marriageand adultery-related homicide cases from the Qing dynasty’s Criminal Case Repots Archives. Of the 73,216 criminal reports from between 1736 and 1896 we identified 3,119 cases that contain price information on wife or concubine sale, widow remarriage, regular marriage, and bride-price. This dataset is then used to investigate if bride-prices would decrease significantly during times when human survival was under pressure or threat. In our analysis, grain price is employed as a proxy for the presence of survival risks: higher grain price signals a shortage of food supply and its severity. For example, a major crop failure due to drought or other natural disasters usually leads to extremely high grain price and challenges the survival of human beings, which pressures more husbands to sell their wives or daughters for liquidity. In turn, this may result in high supply of women on the market, causing supply-demand imbalance. The price of woman traded as wife or concubine, or “bride-price” (a term as used hereafter), will likely fall as a result. We find that grain price (i.e., survival risk) had the most significant impact on bride-price in 18-19 century China: when grain price was high, bride-price would be low. Confucian influence also had a significant influence on bride-price: the deeper the Confucian influence (as reflected by a larger number of chaste women) in a region, the lower the supply of women on the marriage and resale market and hence the * Zhiwu Chen, School of Management, Yale University and School of Economics, Peking University (Visiting Professor) ( zhiwu.chen@yale.edu );Shijun He, Institute of Economics, Tsinghua University(hshj822@163.com);Zhan Lin, Institute of Qing History, Renmin University of China(linzhan126@126.com);Kaixiang Peng, School of Economics, Henan University(kaixiangp@qq.com)。We thank Denggao Long, Weipeng Yuan, Debin Ma, Kang Wang, Yongwei Chen, Ruixue Jia as well as participants at the Second Quantitative History Annual Meeting for valuable comments. We also thank Xuemei Peng, Shixia Qu, Shujuan Liu, Wei Xu, Xiaobin Zheng, Hua Zhang, Tao Gui, Bofang Zhou, Shiting Zhu, Xinliu Yang, Shasha Li, Hao Jia, Liuyang Zhao, Yingmeng Jian, Juan Wang, He Xu, Guangwei Pan, Xiaobing Bao, Zhengliang Gao, Aolin Li, Jingzhu Li, Hui Liu, Lili Mi, Peng Shi, Xiaojin Wan, Zaihong Wang, Zhiqian Xie, Kang Zhang, Lingli Zhang for excellent research assistance. We are responsible for any remaining errors.