Comparison of Water Use Efficiency of Winter Wheat Between Experimental Station and Farm Management Levels

MA Wenjun,CHENG Qinjuan,YU Zhenrong

2010-01-01

Abstract:Improving water use efficiency (WUE) is one of the important ways to alleviate acute conflicts between water resources scarcity and food demand increase in the North China Plain. Based on experimental data at experimental stations and farm survey, differences in WUE for winter wheat between experimental stations and farm management levels were investigated in detail. Combined with experimental data at the farm management level, the feasibility of popularizing the economical fresh water-based irrigation mode at the experimental station management level to farmers’ fields was discussed. Data at the stations were collected from the experiment which aimed at examining the effects of water irrigation on yield of winter wheat in the Quzhou Experimental Station operated by China Agricultural University from 1997 to 2005. Three treatments, i.e., fully irrigated with fresh water, economically irrigated with fresh water, and no irrigation, were designed. Data were collected from a farm survey, in which the effects of planting behavior on yield of winter wheat at 321 farms in Quzhou County from 2003 to 2006 were examined. Two farms were randomly selected to perform the experiment from 2005 to 2006 in Xinyuan, 3 km away from the Quzhou Experimental Station. Three treatments, i.e., farmer independent irrigation, expert suggested irrigation, and no irrigation, were designed. Total water use (TWU) was estimated by the water balance equation. The ratio of irrigation to TWU was first developed to appraise the importance of irrigation for winter wheat at the farm management level. Results showed that the WUE at the experimental station management level was 14.30 kg/(hm2 mm), which was the same as the economical fresh water-based irrigation mode. The WUE of winter wheat for 88.96% of farmers’ fields at the farm management level was generally lower than that at the experimental station management level. This could be ascribed to different planting aims and a large knowledge gap between the researcher and farmer, with farmers’ planting motivation being highly restrained by the household contract responsibility system. WUE among farmers’ fields was vastly different, which was probably caused by differences in soil fertility, farm size and water quality. The economical fresh water-based irrigation mode at the experimental station management level was found to be suited for farmers’ fields, which could maintain high yield and substantially improve the WUE of winter wheat. Strategies to improve WUE at the farm management level in the North China Plain include: further ameliorating policies to promote farmers’ planting motivation, promoting land consolidation to enlarge the area of single fields, improving soil fertility to increase the yield of crops, and eliminating the knowledge gap between the researcher and the farmer.