Abstract:Introduction: Reasoning is a complex form of human cognition whose nature has long been debated. While a number of neurocognitive mechanisms for deductive reasoning have been offered, one of the most prominent accounts is Mental Model Theory (MMT). According to MMT, humans are able to manipulate and represent information for reasoning and problem solving by leveraging the brain's evolved visuospatial resources. Thus, when solving deductive reasoning problems, reasoners build "mental models" of the essential pieces of information conveyed in the premises, with their relations to each other represented spatially-even when the information contained within a reasoning problem is not intrinsically spatial. Crucially, taking a spatially-based approach, such as building mental models, supports higher accuracy on deductive reasoning problems. However, no study has empirically tested whether explicitly training this mental modeling ability leads to improved deductive reasoning performance. Method: Therefore, we designed the Mental Models Training App, a cognitive training mobile application which requires participants to complete increasingly difficult reasoning problems while using an external mental modeling tool. In this preregistered study (https://osf.io/4b7kn), we conducted a between-subjects experiment (N = 301) which compared the Mental Models Training App to 3 distinct control conditions in order to examine which specific components (if any) of the training were causally responsible for improved reasoning performance. Results: Results demonstrate that, when compared to a passive control condition, the Mental Models Training App led to improvements in adults' verbal deductive reasoning performance both during and after the training intervention. However, contrary to our preregistered hypotheses, the training-induced improvements were not significantly larger than the effects of the active control conditions-one which included adaptive practice of the reasoning problems, and one which included adaptive practice as well as a spatial alphabetization control task. Discussion: Therefore, while the present results demonstrate the ability of the Mental Models Training App to enhance verbal deductive reasoning, they do not support the hypothesis that directly training participants mental modeling ability yields improved performance beyond the effects of adaptive practice of reasoning. Future research should examine the long-term effects of repeated usage of the Mental Models Training App, as well as transfer effects to other forms of reasoning. Finally, we present the Mental Models Training App as a free mobile application available on the Apple App store (https://apps.apple.com/us/app/mental-models-training/id1664939931), in the hope that this translational research may be utilized by the general public to improve their reasoning ability.

Are Deductions Built Upon Rules or Models?——Evidences from Data on Spatial Reasoning

The Neural Basis of Spatial Reasoning:An Event-related Potential Study

Deductive‐reasoning brain networks: A coordinate‐based meta‐analysis of the neural signatures in deductive reasoning

An Analysis of the Strategies for Reasoning on Spatial and Non-spatial Relations by Adolescents with Nonverbal Learning Abilities

Author Response for "deductive‐reasoning Brain Networks: A Coordinate‐based Meta‐analysis of the Neural Signatures in Deductive Reasoning"

A Reasoning Method of Spatial Relations on the Spherical Digital Space

The Mental Models Training App: Enhancing verbal reasoning through a cognitive training mobile application

A Review of the Cognitive and Brain Mechanism of Deductive Reasoning

Distinct Neural Substrates of Visuospatial and Verbal-Analytic Reasoning As Assessed by Raven’s Advanced Progressive Matrices

Common and distinct neural substrates of forward-chaining and backward-chaining syllogistic reasoning

The Roles of Working Memory's Components in Transitive Reasoning

A Review of Researches on Reasoning about Temporal Sequence

The Neural Mechanism of Inductive Reasoning

How Far Are We from Intelligent Visual Deductive Reasoning?

A Model for Representing and Reasoning of Spatial Relations Between Simple Concave Regions

Spatial Processing Rather Than Logical Reasoning Was Found to Be Critical for Mathematical Problem-Solving

Exploring The Spatial Reasoning Ability of Neural Models in Human IQ Tests

Qualitative Spatial Reasoning about Topology and Cardinal Direction

Relational Complexity Modulates Activity in the Prefrontal Cortex During Numerical Inductive Reasoning: an Fmri Study.

An Integrated Model for Topology & Direction Relation Reasoning

The Neural Mechanism Of Human Numerical Inductive Reasoning Process: A Combined Erp And Fmri Study