Abstract:Evolutionary game theory, encompassing discrete, continuous, and mixed strategies, is pivotal for understanding cooperation dynamics. Discrete strategies involve deterministic actions with a fixed probability of one, whereas continuous strategies employ intermediate probabilities to convey the extent of cooperation and emphasize expected payoffs. Mixed strategies, though akin to continuous ones, calculate immediate payoffs based on the action chosen at a given moment within intermediate probabilities. Although previous research has highlighted the distinct impacts of these strategic approaches on fostering cooperation, the reasons behind the differing levels of cooperation among these approaches have remained somewhat unclear. This study explores how these strategic approaches influence cooperation in the context of the prisoner's dilemma game, particularly in networked populations with varying clustering coefficients. Our research goes beyond existing studies by revealing that the differences in cooperation levels between these strategic approaches are not confined to finite populations; they also depend on the clustering coefficients of these populations. In populations with nonzero clustering coefficients, we observed varying degrees of stable cooperation for each strategic approach across multiple simulations, with mixed strategies showing the most variability, followed by continuous and discrete strategies. However, this variability in cooperation evolution decreased in populations with a clustering coefficient of zero, narrowing the differences in cooperation levels among the strategies. These findings suggest that in more realistic settings, the robustness of cooperation systems may be compromised, as the evolution of cooperation through mixed and continuous strategies introduces a degree of unpredictability.

Effect of clustering in the scale-free networks on cooperative behavior

Prisoner'S Dilemma Game on Clustered Scale-Free Networks under Different Initial Distributions

The Prisoner's Dilemma in Structured Scale-Free Networks

Evolutionary prisoner's dilemma game on highly clustered community networks

Robustness of Cooperation on Highly Clustered Scale-Free Networks

Prisoner's Dilemma on Community Networks

Role of Clustering Coefficient on Cooperation Dynamics in Homogeneous Networks

Effects Of Learning Activity On Cooperation In Evolutionary Prisoner'S Dilemma Game

Does the scale-free topology favor the emergence of cooperation?

Effects of Average Degree on Cooperation in Networked Evolutionary Game

The Different Cooperative Behaviors on a Kind of Scale-Free Networks with Identical Degree Sequence

Effects of diverse inertia on scale-free–networked prisoner's dilemma games

Mixed strategy approach destabilizes cooperation in finite populations with clustering coefficient

Cooperation Enhanced by the 'survival of the Fittest' Rule in Prisoner'S Dilemma Games on Complex Networks

Asymmetric Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma on BA Scale-Free Network

Influence of initial distributions on robust cooperation in evolutionary Prisoner's Dilemma

Effect of community structure on coevolutionary dynamics with dynamical linking

The topological issues of cooperation

Strategic Games on a Hierarchical Network Model

Invasion of cooperation in scale-free networks: Accumulated vs. average payoffs

Networking effects on evolutionary snowdrift game in networks with fixed degrees