Abstract:Ironically, Andrew Vickers chooses acupuncture and Oscillococcinum as examples of why complementary and alternative medicine is more than just the placebo response. These were unfortunate choices. Acupuncture is the product of 2nd century BC China, a culture that not only didn’t believe in human dissection, but rather punished those who dissected humans by death – a real disincentive to learning about human anatomy. They picked 12 meridians in which to place needles because there are 12 great rivers in China. And they believed that the body consisted of about 360 separate parts because there are about 360 days in the year. So if you don’t believe that the peripheral nervous system is based on rivers in China or days in the year, then the Chinese were merely making stuff up, which doesn’t mean that acupuncture doesn’t work. Vickers ignores the studies of Edzard Ernst showing that acupressure (which involves pressure but not puncture at various points along the meridian) works just as well as acupuncture and is most likely related to a learned endorphin response and probably why the Cochrane Collaboration showed that acupuncture works in some to relieve pain. Great. So let us just do this without putting the needles under the skin. Isn’t it incumbent upon us to evoke a response in the most painless and least dangerous way possible? (More than 80 people have died from acupuncture either from infections like HIV, hepatitis B, or hepatitis C or from needles having dislodged and ended up in hearts, livers, and lungs.) Oscillococcinum is made by taking the heart and liver of a duck, grinding it up, diluting it 100-fold, and repeating that 100-fold dilution 200 more times. Setting aside for the moment why the heart and liver of a duck would treat flu, the final dilution is 10. In other words, the duck is gone. In fact, one would have a hard time finding a single molecule of the duck if the final volume were that of the universe. Yet, Dr Vickers believes that studies have shown the effectiveness of Oscillococcinum when compared to placebo. Ironic, given that Oscillococcinum is placebo. It is a gram of sugar. If a study shows something that is biologically impossible, then it is fair to assume that it wasn’t controlled correctly. Every day, about 4000 studies are published in the world’s literature. As one would predict, those studies follow a bell-shaped curve. Some studies are excellent. Some are poor. And most are more or less mediocre. Said another way, you can find a study to support any hypothesis. The bigger issue is the quality, robustness, internal consistency, and reproducibility of those studies.

Comparison of the Distribution of Laticifers in Diploid and Tetraploid of Euphorbia Tirucalli L.

The Tissue Culture of Liriope Platyphylla Wang Et Tang Var. Variegata Hort.

Cytological Analysis of the Bulblet Initiation and Development in Lycoris Species

In Vitro Induction And Characterization Of Tetraploid Lychnis Senno Siebold Et Zucc.

eJBio: Electronic Journal of Biology

Lysosome and proteasome pathways are distributed in laticifers of Euphorbia helioscopia L.

Ontogenesis of the anastomosed laticifers of Allamanda cathartica (Apocynaceae) and the chemical nature of the stem latex

Changes in Morphological Characteristics, Regeneration Ability, and Polysaccharide Content in Tetraploid Dendrobium officinale

Book Review: Rejoinder from the author

Comparison Between a Tetraploid Turnip and Its Diploid Progenitor (brassica Rapa L.): the Adaptation to Salinity Stress

Cluster Analysis for the Pollen Quantity and Viability of 27 Euphorbia Pulcherrima Cultivars and Comparison of Testing Methods

STUDIES OF ASEXUAL PROPAGATION AND PRELIMINARY STUDY ON MOLECULAR BACKGROUND OF BULB DEVELOPMENT IN LYCORIS SPP.

Transcriptome Profiling Reveals Key Genes in Regulation of the Tepal Trichome Development in Liliumpumilum D.C.

A Comparison of the Immunostimulatory Effects of Polysaccharides from Tetraploid and Diploid Echinacea purpurea

Lactic dehydrogenase and DPN-ase activity of blood.

Nuclear matrix bound terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase in rat thymus nuclei. I. A possible site for TdT mediated function

Opposing roles of plant laticifer cells in the resistance to insect herbivores and fungal pathogens

Induction, identification and characterization of tetraploidy in Lycium ruthenicum

The clonal growth in Aconitum carmichaelii Debx

Comparation of Composition Content and Growth of Tube Culture Plantlet of Dendrobium Candidum Wall. in Different Months.

Phenotypic characterization, plant growth and development, genome methylation, and mineral elements composition of neotetraploid lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.)