The New Geophysics : stress-forecasting as an alternative to earthquake prediction-a paradigm shift

Stuart Crampin,Yuan Gao

2009-01-01

Abstract:This paper suggests that the paradigm shift, before earthquakes can be predicted, is to neglect the impending earthquake source zone, on which most previous prediction techniques have (ineffectually) concentrated, and use shear-wave splitting to monitor stress-accumulation in the rock mass away from the eventual epicentre. Since in situ rock is weak to shear stress, the energy released by large earthquakes must necessarily accumulate over substantial volumes of rock around the impending earthquake source. A new understanding of fluid-rock deformation, a New Geophysics, suggests that such stressaccumulation can be monitored by analysing the effects on shear-wave splitting (seismic birefringence) caused by changes of stress on the geometry of the stress-aligned fluidsaturated microcracks pervading almost all in situ rocks. Observations of shear-wave splitting suggest that large earthquakes occur when all or most of the microcracks in the stressed volume approach fracture-criticality and failure by fracturing. This allows the progress towards fracture-criticality of the highly-compliant fluid-saturated microcrack geometry in most crustal rocks to be monitored and the time and magnitude of an impending larger earthquake stress-forecast. Logarithms of the duration of the stress-accumulation are proportional (self-similar) to the magnitude of the impending event. Knowledge that a large earthquake is approaching allows other precursory data to be interpreted realistically and the location of the fault-plane estimated. Using seismic swarms as the source of shear-waves to monitor the stressed rock, characteristic temporal variations in shear-wave splitting (the inferred stress-accumulation) have been seen in retrospect before some 14 earthquakes worldwide, and on one occasion, the time, magnitude, and fault break of an M 5 earthquake in SW Iceland were successfully stress-forecast in a comparatively narrow time/magnitude window. Unfortunately, the scarcity of suitable seismic swarms for the source of shear-waves, and the irregularity of swarm activity, mean that reliable routine stress-forecasting schemes cannot use seismic swarms as the source of shear-waves. Reliable stress-forecasting requires the precision and controlled-source stability of cross-hole seismics in borehole Stress-Monitoring Sites (SMSs). This paper reviews the evidence for a paradigm shift from earthquake prediction to stress-forecasting and its implications for the future development of SMSs. An appendix proposes GEMS, a Global Earthquake Monitoring System for stress-forecasting all damaging earthquakes worldwide.