Zhu Shunshui and Late-Ming Thoughts
Ryotaro ARAKI,Ming QIAN,Ying ZHONG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-2338.2009.04.002
2009-01-01
Abstract:This paper focuses on Zhu Shunshui's discussions with Ando Seian on "the debate between Zhu Xi and Lu Xiangshan" during his stay in Nagasaki. Before meeting Zhu Shushui,Seian had "kunten-marked" Chen Jian's General Critique of the Obscuration of Learning (Xuebu tongbian) and agreed on Zhu Xi's view rather than Lu Xiangshang's. Later,he consulted Zhu Shunshui on this issue. As a scholar-bureaucrat,Zhu Shunshui had the courage to accept the responsibility for the Ming Dynasty's fall. In reflecting upon the deep reasons for Ming's failure,Zhu Shunshui was able to identify clearly the weaknesses in Lu Xiangshan and Wang Yangming's thoughts. This showed his profound problem consciousness. Zhu Shunshui criticized not only the proposition that Wang Ji's Conscience Existentialism of Yangming School was equal to Buddhism but also the idea that Donglin School's Gao Panlong and Zhou Yuanbiao,and Liu Zongzhou,who had deep relations with Donglin School,were "moralists".