Universal Civilization or Chinese Value:Chinese Historicism in the Last Decade

Xu Jilin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-2938.2010.05.005
2010-01-01
Abstract:Over the last decade,there have been among Chinese thinkers various narratives of "Chinese value","Chinese mode","Chinese subjectivity",etc.What lies behind these narratives is one theoretical presupposition:historicism as in opposition to universal reason.Chinese historicism grew out of the anti-west trend in 1990s.Now,against the backdrop of China emerging as a world power in the 21st century,Chinese historicism goes further to challenge the value of universal civilization,with the belief that history is idiosyncratic and that the state is but a collective representation of all the national idiosyncrasies.It tries to find the special ethos of Chinese nationality as in opposition to western cultural universalism.However,the overall interpretation of China by historicism is ambiguous.Of western civilization,Chinese historicism rejects its value of Enlightenment but accepts its dangerous idea of statism.It can be predicted that the alternative modernity Chinese historicism is pursuing will end up being a de-valued and de-ethicized state power with its system legitimized in the Weberian fashion.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?