Impact of farmland transfer and stability of rental contracts in apple production areas on apple growers’ behaviors for improvement of land quality
Li Xingguang,Huo Xuexi,Liu Jundi,Zhang Huili
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2019.15.034
2019-01-01
Abstract:How to improve land quality is still a big challenge for most of developing countries. Theoretically, whether farmers are willing to improve land quality depends on the size and availability of the benefits of improving land quality. And farmland is a kind of immovable property whose financial return period is relatively long, which means that tenure security can affect the security of residual claims for those farmers who rents farmland. More importantly, the system of China’s farmland property rights is ambiguous resulting in tenure insecurity, which may hinder the development of farmland rental markets and discourage agricultural long-term investment. However, in the context of ambiguous system of farmland property rights, perfect farmland rental contracts are important because these contracts improve the expectation of tenure security. Thus, this paper attempted to examine empirically the influencing mechanisms of farmland transfer and the stability of farmland rental contracts on behaviors of improvement of land quality using OLS model and survey data from a 762 household-level and 1163 plot-level survey in apple production areas of Shaanxi and Shandong province. To ensure the precision of conclusions, we used PSM model, IV method, quasi-natural experiment method and plot-level survey data to solve the endogenous issue. Thus, the empirical results indicated that: 1) farmland transfer could be conducive to expanding farm size and decreasing the costs of the investment of land conservation, which encouraged the investment of farmyard manure and consequently improved land quality; 2) compared with owned plots, the risk of property rights in rented plots was usually higher, which inhibited the investment of farmyard manure; 3) higher rents of farmland transfer were conductive to obtaining the returns on the improvement of land quality in time, which encouraged the investment of farmyard manure; 4) farmland transfer approved by village collectives could encourage the investment of farmyard manure. According to the abovementioned empirical results, we found that the size of the benefits of improving land quality depended on farm size, and the availability of the benefits of improving land quality depended on tenure security. Thus, three policy recommendations can be made: 1) central government should improve the supporting measures for the reform of farmland registration and confirmation, and strengthen the supervision of performing and implementing farmland registration and confirmation; 2) in the context of ambiguous system of farmland property rights, farmland rental contracts should be designed to be more standard and formal, which can be conducive to reducing the opportunistic behaviors and stabilizing the expectation of tenure security for farmers, and government should develop actively farmland rental markets as well; 3) he role of village collectives and their leaders should give full play. Because village collectives and their leaders not only act as the agents of superior governments, but also act as the agents of villagers in their own villages, which can be conducive to improving transaction order within villages and reducing transaction costs.