Abstract:Historic towns and villages are important elements of China's cultural heritage. They now have a recognized value from a tourism perspective; however, the rapid pace of tourism development in such historic towns and villages has resulted in a series of problems brought about by tourism commodification. Mitchell(1998) initially developed a creative destruction model to predict the fate of communities that base their development on the commodification of rural heritage: she later revisited this model(Mitchell and de Waa?l, 2009). She applied the creative destruction model to the village of St. Jacobs, Canada and demonstrated that entrepreneurial investment had fostered the creation of a setting for aesthetic consumption, and that the sub-cultures contribute to the development of a contested landscape of consumption. The model is divided into a six stage process: pre- commodification, early commodification, advanced commodification, early destruction, advanced destruction and postdestruction. Whether or not the final(post- destruction) stage is achieved is dictated by the power struggle that arises among the sub-cultures engaged in the transformation of the rural landscape.This paper applies the creative destruction model to Xidi Village, a world heritage destination in Anhui,China. Xidi Village is an ideal destination to implement the creative destruction model because it satisfies the three premises described by Mitchell: it is accessible to a large affluent population(Shanghai and Suzhou); some heritage elements were in existence before commodification began; and an entrepreneurial spirit existed. This paper uses qualitative research to collect data on investments,tourist numbers and resident attitudes and reveals that Xidi is in the model's third stage(advanced commodification), which is maintained because of the government's forward- looking interventions.This third stage cannot achieve theequilibriumstate that Mitchell(1998) described for the model's second and final stages. However, Xidi exhibits different equilibrium characteristics than those described by Mitchell. In reaching this equilibrium state, the local public sector in Xidi resisted outside investments and limited the local residents' commercial behavior to curtail rapid and pernicious commodification. Moreover, they used tourism income to improve the infrastructure and village landscape, thus satisfying both the local residents and the tourists. The local public sector also planned a new district located outside the old village to situate new investment and government agencies. In contrast to Mitchell's study, the local people in Xidi have never expressed a desire to relocate, both because of the economic benefits that tourism offers them and because of their emotional attachment to the village. Moreover, there has not been an influx of new residents from large cities because the public service in Xidi Village are less developed. This paper asserts that as one of the model's drivers, the local government's attitude in the third stage will determine whether the creative destruction model will progress to its subsequent/advanced stages. This paper proposes a modification to the creative destruction model for China's historic towns and villages. The modification focuses on the role of the local public sector, the state of equilibrium and the attitudes of local residents. The findings should be beneficial to other communities that base their development on the marketing of small-town heritage.

Towards integrated status from discrete actuality——On the mechanism of historic site renewal catalyzed by commerce and tourism

MARKET-ORIENTED RENEWAL OF HISTORIC SITES AND RENOVATION OF PLANNING AD- MINISTRATION

The Historic District Analysis with the "Eco-museum"Concept——Taking Hangzhou Xiaohe Road District for Example

Isolated or Integrated? Planning and Management of Urban Renewal for Historic Areas in Old Beijing City, Based on the Association Network System

Public policies and conservation plans of historic urban landscapes under the sustainable heritage tourism milieu: discussions on the equilibrium model on Kulangsu Island, UNESCO World Heritage site

Historic Quarters Revitalization Motivated by Culture Tourism

Research on Renewal Strategy of Historical and Cultural Blocks from the Perspective of Tourist Perception

Historic Conservation and Tourism Economy: Challenges Facing Adaptive Reuse of Historic Conservation Areas in Chengdu, China

The Multivalent Nexus of Redevelopment and Heritage Conservation: A Mixed-Methods Study of the Site-Level Public Consultation of Urban Development in Macao

TRANSFORMATION OF PLANNING MECHANISM IN URBAN RENEWAL FROM PUBLIC MANAGEMENT’S PERSPECTIVE

The Role of Tourism and Its Limitation in Urban Cultural Heritage Conservation: a Case Study of the Residence of Ganxi in Nanjing

Tourism, Residents Agent Practice and Traditional Residential Landscapes at a Cultural Heritage Site: The Case Study of Hongcun Village, China

Tourism Commodification in China's Historic Towns and Villages:Re-examining the Creative Destruction Model

A study on the path to realize the conservation and utilization of historical buildings and the synergistic development of cities

Approach to Revitalizating Historic Villages Oriented by Tourism

From Xintiandi to Laomendong--The Alienation and Return of the Historical and Cultural Value in Urban Renewal

The Current Situation and Measures of Enning Road Old City Renovation in Guangzhou City

An analysis of tourism revitalization of historic district in perspective of tourist experience:A case study of San-Fang Qi-Xiang district in Fuzhou City

The Study on Strategies for Historic Towns on the Collaborative Development of Space and Culture Based on the Background of Urbanization Transition Period

Urban Transformation in Old Cities of China: From Heritage Preservation to Urban Renewal

Post-Renewal Evaluation of an Urbanized Village with Cultural Resources Based on Multi Public Satisfaction: A Case Study of Nantou Ancient City in Shenzhen