Abstract:Background Estimating the disease prevalence and test accuracy (sensitivity and specificity) for two dependent screening tests when the status of individuals who are negative on both tests is unverified represents a considerable challenge, as the disease rates for individuals negative on both tests are not identifiable without additional assumptions. Methods This article presents a unified framework for handling this non-identifiability problem using two-step hierarchical informative prior on the sensitivities by two-stage Bayesian modeling with the characterized by joint testing strategies based on the inherent attribute of screening/diagnostic tests. We assign a diffuse and less risky two-step hierarchical informative uniform prior to the sensitivities while assigning a uniform (0,1) prior distribution to the specificities and prevalence. Strategies for model evaluation, general global evaluations, and individual cell checking are presented. Simulations are conducted under various scenarios to evaluate the performance of the proposed method. Applications to real data are also presented to illustrate the potential impact and benefit of the proposed method. Results Our results indicate that when the priors of sensitivities are assigned as appropriate two-step hierarchical informative priors, or even in the absence of the priors for the specificities and prevalence, the parameters involved in this study can still be estimated well. The advantages and limitations of this method in solving such problems are discussed and compared with other two-stage methods. Conclusions We developed a two-stage Bayesian method for two dependent dichotomous screening tests with unverified individuals who are negative on both tests, and addressed the ad hoc model evaluation and checking procedures. The method can be understood easily and used conveniently by non-statisticians.

The Evaluation of Some Two-stage Sampling Methods

[Scan Statistic Theory and Its Application in Spatial Epidemiology].

Optimized estimation for population mean using conventional and non-conventional measures under the joint influence of measurement error and non-response

[Weighted Estimation Methods for Multistage Sampling Survey Data].

A Method for Surveying Sensitivity Questions

Optimal two-phase sampling for comparing correlated areas under the ROC curves of two screening tests in the presence of verification bias

On two-stage adaptive cluster sampling to assess pest density.

Comparison of Statistical Methods for Analysis of Threshold Model of Two-Stage Clustered Randomized Data

Correcting Classifiers for Sample Selection Bias in Two-Phase Case-Control Studies

[Application of a Simple Random Sampling Method on Surveys at the Community Level].

Efficient Sampling in Disease Surveillance through Subpopulations: Sampling Canaries in the Coal Mine

Comparison of Different Methods for Analyzing Data Obtained from Stratified Cluster Random Sampling

Unbiased Estimation Method of the Prevalence by Negative Binomial distribution Sampling

Data Analysis Method in World Health Survey - China Survey

[Data Analysis from Surveys Using Complex Sampling Methods].

A Survey of Variable Selection Methods in Two Chinese Epidemiology Journals

Rejective Sampling, Rerandomization and Regression Adjustment in Survey Experiments

Simple estimators for network sampling

A Two-Stage Bayesian Method for Estimating Accuracy and Disease Prevalence for Two Dependent Dichotomous Screening Tests when the Status of Individuals Who Are Negative on Both Tests is Unverified

Interval Estimation of Age-adjusted Rate and its Application in Estimation for Cervix Cancer Prevalence

Comparison of tests for categorical data from a stratified cluster randomized trial