Comparative Study of the Three Current DNA Extraction Methods from the Activated Sludge for Genome DNA Based on the Quantitative PCR
Pei HUANG,Fei YE,Sheng-jun WU,Ping HUANG,Shan YANG,Yuan-you TAN,Yu WANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13637/j.issn.1009-6094.2016.03.044
2016-01-01
Abstract:The paper aimed to present the results of our comparative study of the three DNA extractive methods from the activated sludge based on the quantitative PCR for genome DNA in hoping to choose the most suitable one for the purpose.We have carefully compared the three methods for DNA isolation on the basis of comparing the concentrations and purity of the DNA yielded as well as the results of the quantitative PCR of the bacteria 16S rRNA.The three methods include BTK DNA isolation kit based on the complex enzymatic-chemical lysis,the PS DNA isolation kit method based on the beads beating-SDS lysis and the CTAB (Hexadecyltrimethyl Ammonium Bromide) assay based on the lysozyme lysis.According to the results of comparison in the concentration and yield of DNA that have been extracted by using the three methods,the yield of CTAB assay accounts for 496.3-1 715.3 pg/mL,whereas the purest DNA can be gained by the BTK kit (A260/A280 ＞ 1.76,A260/A230 ＞ 1.9).What is more,the bacterial 16S rRNA gene was retrieved successfully by the quantitative PCR with 500-fold diluted DNA from the aforementioned three methods.The DNA from the method of BTK kit (3.7 × 106-8.6 × 106 copies/g) was compared with that from PS kit (7.1× 106-1.3 × 107 copies/g).In comparison with the other two methods,the DNA gained from the method of CTAB (1.9 × 108-1.4 × 1010 copies/g) turns to be higher than that from the other two methods.Besides,little difference has been found of the quantitative results in diluting muhiple with the DNA from PS kit,in which the results of 500-fold dilution have been found 22.01,3.46,3.3,1.81 times higher than those of 100-fold from the other two methods,respectively.The amount of bacterial 16S rRNA gained through the CTAB method tends to be conspicuously higher than the rest two commercial kits,whose abundance was comparable to the concentration of the yielded DNA,though the purity from CTAB doesn' t seem so good as those from BTK method.However,the impact of the method tends to be diminished due to the increase of the multiplicity of dilution (500 times as in this study).In addition,it has been found easy to obtain the reagent for CTAB,which can thus have greatly reduced the cost for its application and therefore,becomes highly economic.Based on the results of our study of the three aforementioned methods,we prefer to recommend the CTAB method for DNA extraction for the activated sludge.