Abstract:Objectives: To examine the impact of patient-mix on National Health Service (NHS) acute hospital trust scores in two national NHS patient surveys. Methods: Secondary analysis of 2012 patient survey data for 57,915 adult inpatients at 142 NHS acute hospital trusts and 45,263 adult emergency department attendees at 146 NHS acute hospital trusts in England. Changes in trust scores for selected questions, ranks, inter-trust variance and score-based performance bands were examined using three methods: no adjustment for case-mix; the current standardization method with weighting for age, sex and, for inpatients only, admission method; and a regression model adjusting in addition for ethnicity, presence of a long-term condition, proxy response (inpatients only) and previous emergency attendances (emergency department survey only). Results: For both surveys, all the variables examined were associated with patients' responses and affected inter-trust variance in scores, although the direction and strength of impact differed between variables. Inter-trust variance was generally greatest for the unadjusted scores and lowest for scores derived from the full regression model. Although trust scores derived from the three methods were highly correlated (Kendall's tau coefficients 0.70-0.94), up to 14% of trusts had discordant ranks of when the standardization and regression methods were compared. Depending on the survey and question, up to 14 trusts changed performance bands when the regression model with its fuller case-mix adjustment was used rather than the current standardization method. Conclusions: More comprehensive case-mix adjustment of patient survey data than the current limited adjustment reduces performance variation between NHS acute hospital trusts and alters the comparative performance bands of some trusts. Given the use of these data for high-impact purposes such as performance assessment, regulation, commissioning, quality improvement and patient choice, a review of the long-standing method for analysing patient survey data would be timely, and could improve rigour and comparability across the NHS. Performance comparisons need to be perceived as fair and scientifically robust to maintain confidence in publicly reported data, and to support their use by both the public and the NHS.

Delving into Casemix and its application

Evaluating Performance of Local Case-Mix System by International Comparison: a Case Study in Beijing, China.

Casemix funding for acute hospital inpatient services in Australia

International casemix and funding models: lessons for rehabilitation

Performance Evaluation of Inpatient Service in Beijing: a Horizontal Comparison with Risk Adjustment Based on Diagnosis Related Groups

Evaluation of the performance of diagnosis-related groups and similar casemix systems: methodological issues

Establishment of Hospital Disease Evaluation and Management System Based on the Concept of Case -mix

Validation of a quantitative instrument measuring critical success factors and acceptance of Casemix system implementation in the total hospital information system in Malaysia

Impact of case-mix on comparisons of patient-reported experience in NHS acute hospital trusts in England

PP265 Application Of A Case-Mix Method For Medical Consumables Management In Anhui Province, China Using Healthcare Big Data

Service Mix, Market Competition, and Cost Efficiency: A Longitudinal Study of U.S. Hospitals

Application of Case Mix Index in Differential Evaluation of Diagnosis and Treatment Behavior

Developing a case mix classification for child and adolescent mental health services: the influence of presenting problems, complexity factors and service providers on number of appointments*

Analytical Techniques to Support Hospital Case Mix Planning

Medical Service Performance Evaluation Based on Case-Mix

Development of a Novel Hospital Payment System – Big Data Diagnosis & Intervention Packet

Introduction to Two-Part Models and Its Calculation with SAS GLIMMIX Procedure

Case Mix and Patient Experiences of Cancer Care

Design and application of the hospital performance assessment indicators based on disease se-verity

SUMix: Mixup with Semantic and Uncertain Information

Expected effects of the mixed payment of " Global budget and Service unit" ( Ⅴ): providing a balanced environment between financing and expenditures for insurance fund