Abstract:A seemingly universal lesson is that anything taken to its extreme is detrimental. Indeed, there has been growing interest in testing this idea within psychology. These studies have often been framed in terms of Aristotle’s doctrine of the golden mean or the idea that virtue lies between the vices of deficiency and excess. Recent explicit reviews of this hypothesis in the psychological literature have led to the paradoxical conclusion that one can have too much virtue (i.e., the too-much-of-a-good-thing effect) despite virtue being identified by the golden mean. We argue in this article that this conclusion is due to a reductionist account of virtues in psychology and the resultant measurement of virtues as general dispositional tendencies in behavior. We review philosophical theory on the golden mean to show that the relationship between virtue and relevant behavior is fundamentally about situation-specific optimality. Using schematic models, we contrast the former measurement approach against the latter to explain the too-much-of-a-good-thing effect and further demonstrate why virtues cannot be properly measured as general tendencies in behavior. We conclude with methodological implications of our theory-informed approach to virtue measurement for research design, evaluation, and conceptualization.

The Characteristics of Virtue Ethics

The Fundamental Concept and the Main Task of Ethics of Virtue from Aristotelianism's Perspective

On Revival of Virtue Ethics

The Reflection of Humanistic Value Between Chinese Classics and Western Classics

An Analysis of Moral Classification vs the Identification of Life Value

Kant’s Virtue Theory

Social and Personality Psychological View on Ethical Virtues: the Meanings,Puzzles and Solutions of Moral Traits

Tracing the Origin of Concepts in Western Ethics: An Existentialist Interpretation of Aristotle's Ethical Concepts

Virtue Ethics and Confucian Ethics

No Worries for Benevolent Person:On Confucian Issues from the Angle of Virtue Ethics

Three sources of wisdom of Chinese traditional virtue and a contemporary examination

Confucian Virtue Jurisprudence

Beyond Dominance and Competence: A Moral Virtue Theory of Status Attainment

The Bridge Between Morality and Education: An Overview of Ancient Chinese Family Virtue Thought

A Sketch of Confucian Virtue Jurisprudence

Values and Worldview of Chinese Civilization

Lost in Translation: The Construct Representation of Character Virtues

The Theory of Ethics in Mencius’Philosophy

The Humanistic Character of Confucianism Seen from the Perspective of the Relationship between Virtue and Happiness

Virtue Theory for Moral Enhancement