Abstract:BackgroundThe Chinese Government has announced plans to reform provider-payment methods at public hospitals by moving from fee-for-service to prospective and aggregated methods including diagnosis-related groups (DRG) to control health expenditures. In 2012, Beijing pioneered China's first DRG payment system in six hospitals. The aim of this study was to explore the effectiveness of Beijing's DRG pilot reform in reducing expenditures, out-of-pocket payments, and potential behaviors to circumvent payment control, including readmissions, selection, and cost-shifting.MethodsWe obtained discharge data from the Beijing Health Insurance Bureau for the period January, 2010, to September, 2012, from 14 tertiary general hospitals, which included six hospitals piloting DRGs within a portion of their payment system and eight control hospitals that implemented purely fee-for-service-based payment. Using a differences-in-differences design, we used hospital discharge data to assess the pilot's impact on cost containment. We did regression analyses to assess associations of DRG payment with outcome variables of health expenditures, length-of-stay, and out-of-pocket payment. The study was approved by Peking University Committee for Biomedical Researches.FindingsPost-reform, there were 36 780 cases using DRG payments and 50 322 cases in the control hospitals paid through fee-for-service. Our findings showed that DRG payment led to ¥1251 (6·2%) reductions in health expenditure and ¥647 (10·5%) reductions in out-of-pocket payment per admission. Length of stay or cost-shifting did not differ between DRG and non-DRG cases. Readmission rates were reduced (–1·4%) with DRG payment relative to non-DRG. About 19 814 (35%) potential DRG cases, however, were reverted back to fee-for-service-based payment. Hospitals processed the payment of older patients with more complications through fee-for-service payment, circumventing the effectiveness of payment reform.InterpretationFor China and other low-income and middle-income countries to fully implement prospective payment systems, such as DRG payments, without allowing circumvention seen in a partially implemented system, it might first be necessary to strengthen core monitoring and technological systems that would support feasibility of DRG payments. Continuous evidence-based monitoring and assessment, partnered with adequate management systems, are necessary to enable these countries to broadly implement DRGs and refine payment systems.FundingChina Medical Board (grant number CMB-OC-12-120).

Theoretical analysis on the behavior change of tertiary hospitals under global budgeting in Shanghai

Research on the effect of global budgeting in social health insurance on the tertiary hospitals in Shanghai

Strategy Analysis of the Implementation of Global Budget in the Tertiary Specialized Comprehensive Public Hospital

Evaluation on the Implementation Effects of Global Budget in the Secondary and Tertiary Hospitals of Beijing

Effects and problems in the global budget management of health insurance in Shanghai

To explore a breakthrough of health reform in China through changing payment(Ⅰ):the prominent practice effects and hints of the policy called "Global budget,Structure adjustment" in Shanghai

Effect on implementation of global budge：Based on micro-data of four pilot hospitals in Beijing

Analysis on the Economic Operation of 8 Tertiary Hospitals in Shanghai from 2012 to 2015

The Impact of a Pilot Reform on the Diagnosis-Related-groups Payment System in China: a Difference-in-difference Study

Economic operation analysis of 8 tertiary hospitals in Shanghai

Can a global budget improve health care efficiency? Experimental evidence from China

The effects of global budget on cost control and readmission in rural China: a difference-in-difference analysis

Evaluation of the Effects of Global Budget Policy on Hospitalization Expenditure by Matching Difference-in-difference Model

Effect Evaluation of Global Budget of Medical Insurance in Beijing

Economic operation analysis of 36 urban secondary hospitals in Shanghai

Economic operation analysis of 13 suburban secondary hospitals in Shanghai

Control Costs, Enhance Quality, and Increase Revenue in Three Top General Public Hospitals in Beijing, China

The Effects of the Multi-Hospital Global Budget Payment on Medical Expenditure and Service Volume: The Evidence from Dangyang County, China

Analysis on Medical Cost Control in Chongqing Public Hospitals from 2011 to 2015

On the Effect of Global Budget Reform on Outpatient Drug Use in County-level Public Hospitals

Research on Shanghai health accounts,2012