Abstract:Purpose Academic contention occurs when research evidence is amenable to more than one interpretation. China has a long tradition of Shang Que (商榷), in which authors argue for their preferred interpretation. The modern form of this tradition is the Shang Que article, which often takes the form of research papers in Chinese-language journals and which tends to be question-oriented. Shang Que articles usually take the views of a particular author or article as the focus of independent and complete criticism by another, independent, academic. This paper explains the role of Shang Que articles in Chinese scholarship and their influence on international academia. Design/methodology/approach A bibliometric analysis was used to explore the characteristics and evolution of Chinese Shang Que articles using 30,577 articles published between 1979 and 2018. Microsoft Excel and Gephi were used for data analysis and visualization. Findings Findings suggest a decline in the number of Shang Que articles and an increase in the number of co-authors. Shang Que articles remained particularly prominent in Philosophy and Humanities and Social Sciences, where they focused on local issues such as classical Chinese, the Sinicization of Marxism and Chinese literature. This suggests that the number of Shang Que articles is related to the degree of internationalization of a research field. Originality/value Shang Que articles, which have been influenced by academic paradigms in English, are a fusion of China's Shang Que tradition and of the modern academic system. Through considering Shang Que articles, this paper explores the benefits of local academic traditions in non-English-speaking cultures.

Studies of Overseas Chinese Literature

A Review of Studies from Mainland China on Overseas Chinese:Retrospect and Prospect

A New Horizon of the Study of Classical Chinese Literature

A Globalized Orientation of Comparative Literature in China

Cultural Anthropology in Relation to the Integration of Studies on Overseas Chinese Literature

Overseas and Ethnic Chinese Studies in the Philippines:An Overview and Some Considerations

Foreign New Literature——Taking as an example the relationship between Zhou Zuoren in his later years and Hong Kong literature

Formation of the Community of Modern Overseas Chinese and the Transmission and Acception of Chinese Novel and Opera

An Overview of Foreign Literature Studies in China from 1949 to 2019

A New Orientation in Chinese-Western Comparative Literature: From Homogeneity to Variation

Data analysis of overseas chinese literature based on co-occurrence relationship

From hunan province to the world : on hu lianggui's comparative literature research

American literature in Chinese perspectives

Within and Without: Chinese Writers Overseas

A Review and Reflection of Overseas Urban China Researches

Oversea Writing of Chinese Film History:Paradigmatic Construction and Theoretical Development

Chinese school of comparative literature: Thirty years of development

On World Literatures, Comparative Literature, And (Comparative) Cultural Studies

A Chinese academic tradition examined in the context of international academic communication: exploratory research into Shang Que articles

Travel and Cultural Understanding: Comparing Victorian and Chinese Literati Travel Writing

Focuses in the Study of Foreign Literature in Recent-year China