Abstract:The statement "The earth is flat" is factually inaccurate, but if someone truly believes and argues in its favor, it is not deceptive. Research on deception detection and fact checking often conflates factual accuracy with the truthfulness of statements. This assumption makes it difficult to (a) study subtle distinctions and interactions between the two and (b) gauge their effects on downstream tasks. The belief-based deception framework disentangles these properties by defining texts as deceptive when there is a mismatch between what people say and what they truly believe. In this study, we assess if presumed patterns of deception generalize to German language texts. We test the effectiveness of computational models in detecting deception using an established corpus of belief-based argumentation. Finally, we gauge the impact of deception on the downstream task of fact checking and explore if this property confounds verification models. Surprisingly, our analysis finds no correlation with established cues of deception. Previous work claimed that computational models can outperform humans in deception detection accuracy, however, our experiments show that both traditional and state-of-the-art models struggle with the task, performing no better than random guessing. For fact checking, we find that Natural Language Inference-based verification performs worse on non-factual and deceptive content, while prompting Large Language Models for the same task is less sensitive to these properties.

Analysis of the Concepts of Fraud and Deception

On Fraudulent Acts of Crime of Fraud

On the Property Loss in Deception Crime

The deception faucet: A metaphor to conceptualize deception and its detection

Analysis on Problems about Elements of the Crime of Fraud on Letter of Credit

A multi-dimensional analysis of deception

On the Lexical Characteristics of Deception

Distribution of Fraud Using Electronic Payment Means (Article 159.3 Criminal Code of the Russian Federation) from Related Crimes

The Difference between Theft and Plunder

Ontology-Based Fraud Detection

Analysis of Objective Problems in the Elements of the Crime of Fraud on Commercial Instruments

The Research on Deception Mechanism of Network Fraud

A Method Based on the Rough Neural Network for Analysing Deception Risks

Text Analysis in Adversarial Settings: Does Deception Leave a Stylistic Trace?

How Entangled is Factuality and Deception in German?

On the Cognition Errors of Facts in the Crime of Financial Fraud

Detecting Deception through Linguistic Analysis

On Perfection and Interpretation of Crime of Fraud of Financing

The formal-logical characterisation of lies, deception, and associated notions

Honesty Is the Best Policy: Defining and Mitigating AI Deception

A Game-Theoretic Foundation of Deception: Knowledge Acquisition and Fundamental Limits