Sinicized Study on the Limit of Criminal Sanction

Wang Cong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-5101.2011.03.009

2011-01-01

Abstract:The philosophy of limiting criminal sanction was introduced for the integrated function of criminal law in Human Rights and Rechtsgut,whose intension referred to limit,supplement,economy and light.On the perspectives of chinization,the paper explores the sinicized intension,circumstance and path.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Jurisprudential Reflections on Community Correction

YE Liang-fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-0169.2007.01.018

2007-01-01

Abstract:Community Correction refers to a kind of criminal justice activity in which a non-custodial penalty or an alternative way of sentence services is executed in the community.The popularity of community correction is attributed to the enlightened penalty opinions,the criminal legislative grounds and the pressing practice demands.The merits of community correction lie in the facilitation of criminal's re-socialization,the realization of multiple penal aims and the embodiment of modern humanistic spirits.
The Development of the New Conduct without Value Theory in China

Zhou Guangquan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14111/j.cnki.zgfx.2012.01.009

2012-01-01

Abstract:With regard to the problem of the theory of substantive illegality playing an important part in crime theory system,an antagonism exists between the consequence without value theory emphasizing "bad consequences" and the(dual) theory of conduct without value emphasizing "‘bad consequences’caused by ‘criminal behaviors’".The study of these two theories,however,has not been well developed in the field of criminal law in China.The theory of reasonable illegality should consider how certain movement of body causes harm to legal interests through violating the code of conduct with a view to establishing a "new conduct without value theory".The(dual) theory of conduct without value in this sense will not extend the scope of penalty or breach human rights;in addition,continuing to hold the standpoint of the theory of objective illegality will not obscure the confines of liability and responsibility.The new conduct without value theory can make crime theory and penalty theory unite harmoniously,confirm the positive aim of general prevention of penalty and agree with the current situation of social development,legislative tendency and judicial practice.
On Ideas of Limited Powers in Lun Yu (The Discourse and Saying of Confucius) and Its Modern Values in the Society Ruled by Law

Fu Lin

2000-01-01

Abstract:This article discusses the ideas of limited powers of Confucius,which is the essence of policies ruling a state raised by Confucius,and its modern values to the construction of a state ruled by law.
A sociosemiotic approach to fundamental rights in China

Le Cheng,Shifeng Ni,Kingkui Sin,Winnie Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/sem-2012-0038

2012-01-01

Semiotica

Abstract:The legal term "fundamental rights" has been well recognized in international treaties and legislations. The present study investigates the stipulations on fundamental rights in the four versions (1954, 1975, 1978, and 1982) of and four Amendments (1988, 1993, 1999, and 2004) to the Constitution of the People's Republic of China (PRC) from a sociosemiotic perspective. The findings in this study indicate that the provisions in the Constitution are crafted in such a manner that the dominant social and political participants employ them to maintain their ruling position and promote social and economic developments. In the successive versions and Amendments to the PRC Constitution, the evolution of the provisions on fundamental rights not only demonstrates the development of fundamental rights in China, but also illuminates the underlying mediation mainly among the Chinese government, the Communist Party of China (CPC), and Chinese people. The connotation and validity therein is constructed through communication and competition among various participants. It is therefore argued that the status quo of fundamental rights in China is the result of mediation among the relevant participants under the impact of the social and economic development. The State and the CPC are thus suggested to loosen their grips to promote Chinese people's participation in the mediation process with more attention to the social and economic reality. This study also implies that the definition of a legal term is constrained by other sign systems and hence the importance of an understanding of terminological dynamicity.
Contemporary or Lasting?——A Administrative Law Perspective for CAR Ban

YU Lingyun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-0221.2008.05.003

2008-01-01

Abstract:We thought that the limit of deriving in according to single-or-double and other limits not only had an extensive effect,but also deal with some conflicts between different interest groups.At the same time,the positive point and the negative point whether the limit measure continued are more unilateral.Today,in the course of implement the rule of law in China,the problem is resolved through the idea of rule of law and human rights properly.Therefore,we invited four scholars respectively from different fields of jurisprudence,constitutional law,administrative law and civil law discuss the problem focused by the whole society.
Some Issues on the "Objective Punishment Condition"

Li Hong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-3275.2010.01.004

2010-01-01

Abstract:In the theory of the criminal constitution in China,there is no room for the "surpassing objective elements" of the objective punishment condition.From the perspective that the crime is a conduct which endangers the society,the "surpassing objective elements",as a result which has something to do with the conductor,reveals the degree that the conductor should be punished.It is also a sign of the degree to punish the conduct which endangers the society.Moreover,it should be within the recognition of the conductor but not beyond.
The Specific Provisions of Criminal Code and the Basic Theory of Criminal Law' s Interpretation

Bai Jianjun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-1707.2005.04.012

2005-01-01

Abstract:The 425 pieces of crime stipulated in the Special Provisions of China's Criminal Law embodied all the theory, rule and policy underlying its General Provisions. Meanwhile, the application of Special Provisions fed back the General Provisions and their evolution process with the follows: the diversity and levity of crimes committed in real world, as well as the endogenetic limitation of the rule and theory.Starting from six basic concepts such as abstract accusation and further reviewing the main theoretic issues therewith,this article addressed one antique yet frontier problem - the conflict between and among standards of criminal law interpretation.
The Vicissitudes of Chinese Criminal Law and Theory

Genlin Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/20517483.2017.1330808

2017-01-01

Peking University Law Journal

Abstract:Modern Chinese criminal law and legal theory cannot be separated from the historical, cultural and political context in which they developed. This article begins with a four-part periodization of the development of Chinese criminal law: (1) Late Qing reform, Republican legislation and the dawn of the modernization of Chinese criminal law from the 1911 Revolution until 1949; (2) the blank period of criminal law from the establishment of the PRC in 1949 until 1979; (3) the 1979 Criminal Law and the special Criminal Law era from 1980 until 1997; (4) the 1997 Criminal Law and the amendment era from 1997 to the present. This article next traces the development of Chinese legal scholarship alongside shifts in the criminal law. Prior to 1949 the academic field of Chinese criminal legal studies engaged with criminal justice systems and philosophies from Germany, Japan and other civil law jurisdictions as they were being introduced into China. After the establishment of the PRC, Chinese criminal law turned away from modeling Germany and Japan and thoroughly adopted Soviet criminal theory, transforming Chinese criminal jurisprudence into socialist criminal jurisprudence. In the 1960s and 70s, with the rising tides of legal nihilism and legal anarchism, research into criminal theory stagnated and was suspended for two decades. Following the promulgation of the 1979 Criminal Law, research into criminal legal theory was reinvigorated. Since the mid-1990s research into theory has flourished as a result of theoretical debates and legislative deliberation around the revision to the Criminal Law in 1997. At the turn of the 21st century Chinese criminal legal theory once again incorporated Germany and Japanese criminal law discourse and knowledge, producing systemic reconstruction in a process of standardization.
A Study of the Research Mode on the Traditional Legal Ideology of the Ancient China --citing an Example of "rite and Punishment" from the Confucianism Theory Before the Qin Dynasty

REN Qiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-2397.2001.01.003

2001-01-01

Abstract:The article does an expansive research on the theory of Hume's "fact-judgment" and "value-judgment " by utilizing the theories of Marx Webber's "ideal type" and Wittgenstein's "family resemblance", helping to draw a conclusion to the transformation of Hume's theory from absolute rationality of the essentialism to relative rationality of non-essentialism reason. Based on non-essential "fact-judgment" and "value-judgment", and illustrating the "Rite-punishment" in the Confucianism theory before the Qin Dynasty, the author puts forward two ideal types of research on the Chinese traditional legal ideology-rehabilitation and explanation, advance and creation. On the basis of the two ideal types, we can overcome the blindness and confusion of research on the traditional Chinese legal thoughts and can establish minimum rules in explanation and dialogue so as to deepen the research on the study, and promote the creativity of thought.
Community Correction and the Modification of the Criminal Law

Yong SHAN,He-sheng Xu

2012-01-01

Abstract:As the community correction system develops from a local pilot to nationwide popularization,community correction has the from-the-policy-to-the-law evolution trends.Progressive,conservative and strict legislation pattern is community correction legislation's more scientific,feasible choice,developing from the subsidiary norms of criminal law and criminal procedure law and regulations to separate and systematic Community Corrections Act.Based on rule of law spirit and human rights principles,the core of criminal law modification and future formation of community correction law cannot be only limited to the reasonable distribution criminal implementation right to the correction body,and we Should be concerned about how to scientifically set up mechanisms,especially community governance,to promote a fundamental change from "the correction in the community" to "relying on community correction".
On the " Strike-hard Campaign" in the Perspective of Criminal Integration

孙国祥

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-8860.2004.04.016

2004-01-01

Abstract:The strike-hard campaign is not only an important criminal policy in present China but a hot issue in law circles. Theoretical foundations can be easily found for or against it. In fact, strike-hard campaign not only has brought deterrence theory into full play and satisfied public ideas of revenge but showed idea of heavy penalty believing in omnipotence of penalty. Although strike-hard campaign is necessary for controlling crimes, it bears on obvious administrative coercion and character of rule by man. In perspective of criminal integration, we should objectively evaluate strike-hard campaign , integrate it with other criminal policies, criminal substantive law and procedural law, among which the combination of punishment with leniency should be basis of our criminal policies.
Community Correction,its Current Situation,and How to Approach It in China

WANG Cui-zhu,WANG Shi-zhou

2012-01-01

Abstract:As a totally new object,how far community correction could go on in China is decided by the social conditions of China,theoretical foundation,institutional conditions and the available resources,and sufficient acknowledge of possible difficulties is more important in China's practice of community correction.This article will discuss some basic issues in community correction,and argues that the community correction will be a new beginning of China's Criminal judicial reform,especially in penalty reform.To achieve the pull effect on the criminal penalty structure,we should observe,experience,and modify the measures of community correction scientifically and modestly after the legislation of it in the criminal law.
Functionalist Interpretation of Legal History and Its Limits——A review on Law and Society in Traditional China by Ch'u T'ung-tsu

Sun Guo-dong

2008-01-01

Abstract:The functionalist identity in Law and Society in Traditional China is mainly embodied in its integral conception of culture,ie.allegations of ancient as a whole in diachronic dimension and determinism of law in synchronic dimension.The integral conception of culture reached through the synchronization of diachronic problems has a disadvantage of simplification because of its blindness of legal or social changes and small tradition,and its interpretation of legal history adulterates personal preferences because of its presuppositions of unilinear evolutionism of Maine's edition and the modernization model of after the West.It does not overcome the paradoxes between asserting on one hand the functional analyses of and affirming the integral conception of culture and unilinear evolutionism on the other hand.
Study on Criminal Jurisprudence: Western Countries' Experience and China's Reality

ZHOU Guang-quan

2006-01-01

Abstract:Criminal jurisprudence in China is faced with double missions: one is to modify and reform the theoretical structure,the other is to enhance our perception of issues and problems.Therefore,it is necessary to do trans-culture study on criminal jurisprudence.There are some experience distilled from the development of western criminal law systems,such as interpretation of criminal law by judges, emphasis on the objectivism of criminal law,diversified methodologies and analysis of both system and issues,while there are various problems in the development of criminal jurisprudence in China.Multiple ways are possible to make reform on the future China's criminal jurisprudence theory,including emphasizing on the objectivism of criminal law,constructing a layered system of criminal theory,insisting on substantive criminal theory and improving analysis of current issues.
Theory of Criminal Constitutive Elements:Relationship Confusion and Conquer

周光权

2003-01-01

Abstract:The theory of crime constitution in the criminology of China has not properly dealt with the following relationships between the five pairs of opposite categories: form and substance, prosecution and defense, objectiveness and subjectiveness, experience and norm, static state and process. The theory cannot self-support and must be reasonably improved. There might be a lot of ways to settle the limitations in the theory of crime constitution. One of the ways worth considering is to make judgment about the crime establishment in different “hierarchy” according to the doctrine of criterion violation, but not the doctrine of legal interest violation. At different stages of evaluation, the issues such as “criterion expectation”,“criterion destruction”, and “criterion re-construction”.
The Notion of the Criminal Law in Contemporary China

Chen Xingliang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-9428.2008.03.023

2008-01-01

Abstract:The notion of the criminal law has great significance in the process of building the criminal legal system.Three notions of criminal law should be followed in contemporary China:the notion of human rights safeguard emphasizes the protection of rights of the suspect,the accused,or the offender;the notion of modesty and restraint requires a moderate application of the penalty;and the formal rationality notion accentuates the formal interpretation method of the criminal law.Abundant connotations and prescription of these three notions should be correctly grasped.
Strictly Restrict the Scope and the Punishments of Aggregated Consequential Offences

Zhang Mingkai

2005-01-01

Abstract:The numerous aggregated consequential offences in Chinese Criminal Law are remnant of the consequential responsibility. The scope of the aggregated consequential offences should be strictly restricted as following: the aggregated consequence should go beyond the constitutive elements of a crime; the victim should be the same one of the previous crime; etc. Sentencing should restrict the aggregated consequential offences, too.
An empirical analysis of criminal sanctions against exam cheating in China

Lifeng Li,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu25.2024.205

2024-01-01

Pravovedenie

Abstract:In order to ensure the sustainability of the national examination system, which is the basis of social mobility, China has added new criminal sanctions for Exam Cheating in the criminal law amendment in 2015, and issued the latest judicial interpretation in 2019. However, through the analysis of the relevant judicial application data from 2015 to 2019 by SPSS, it is found that there is still a certain gap between the latest judicial interpretation and the actual problems. To a large extent, the judicial interpretation in 2019 solved the problems of the scope of the crimes of exam cheating and clarified its boundary with other related crimes. However, it does not contain detailed provisions on “serious circumstances”, which will certainly affect the original purpose of legal regulation laid down by the legislator to prevent illegal acts and formulate lawful behavior. Through the empirical research on such crimes, this article argues that the functions of criminal law in shaping the moral and behavior standard could give full play only by revising the penalty standards through later judicial interpretation. Such measures are extremely necessary and will achieve the goal that the legislator pursued when introducing liability for cheating.
Marxist Philosophic Sinicization: Interpretation

LIU Jun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-881x.2007.01.003

2007-01-01

Abstract:It is the core of the Sinicization of Marxist Philosophy that the integration of Marxism and Chinese traditional philosophy.The Sinicization of Marxist Philosophy is the inexorable trend of Marxism's propagation around the world,and it is the inevitable outcome of the development of Chinese traditional philosophy.The ultimate aim of the sinicization of Marxist Philosophy is to establish the new formation of philosophy,and it will bring the new theoretical resources to the development of the global civilization in the Post-Industrial Age.
Criminalization and Decriminalization in Judicature

Zhang Mingkai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-0221.2008.04.011

2008-01-01

Abstract:It is practically of importance to study the criminalization and decriminalization in judicature. The accurate meaning of the criminal law is found grudually in the social life facts. The criminalization in judicature does not break the principle of legality. The judicial organs should be positive to promote the criminalization under the second part of Aricle 3 of the criminal law. The first part of Aricle 3 is not the content of the principle of legality, and its function is to limit the power of decriminalization of juditial organs and control the judicial decriminalization. Such content is fit for the characteristics of the articles of the specific part of criminal law of China. The judicial decriminalization is very limited according to the laws of China, so the ideas and schemes in the criminal justice of some western countries could not be copied in the criminal practice in China.

Sinicized Study on the Limit of Criminal Sanction

Jurisprudential Reflections on Community Correction

The Development of the New Conduct without Value Theory in China

On Ideas of Limited Powers in Lun Yu (The Discourse and Saying of Confucius) and Its Modern Values in the Society Ruled by Law

A sociosemiotic approach to fundamental rights in China

Contemporary or Lasting?——A Administrative Law Perspective for CAR Ban

Some Issues on the "Objective Punishment Condition"

The Specific Provisions of Criminal Code and the Basic Theory of Criminal Law' s Interpretation

The Vicissitudes of Chinese Criminal Law and Theory

A Study of the Research Mode on the Traditional Legal Ideology of the Ancient China --citing an Example of "rite and Punishment" from the Confucianism Theory Before the Qin Dynasty

Community Correction and the Modification of the Criminal Law

On the " Strike-hard Campaign" in the Perspective of Criminal Integration

Community Correction,its Current Situation,and How to Approach It in China

Functionalist Interpretation of Legal History and Its Limits——A review on Law and Society in Traditional China by Ch'u T'ung-tsu

Study on Criminal Jurisprudence: Western Countries' Experience and China's Reality

Theory of Criminal Constitutive Elements:Relationship Confusion and Conquer

The Notion of the Criminal Law in Contemporary China

Strictly Restrict the Scope and the Punishments of Aggregated Consequential Offences

An empirical analysis of criminal sanctions against exam cheating in China

Marxist Philosophic Sinicization: Interpretation

Criminalization and Decriminalization in Judicature