Survey and analysis about the working state of young physicians engaged in the clinical teaching
李岩,李海潮,王颖,刘刚,齐建光,徐阳,周国鹏,刘占兵
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-677X.2014.06.035
2014-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the feelings of young physicians engaged in clinical medical education,and their training backgrounds in teaching ability,to learn their difficulties and the need for helps.Methods 437 attending physicians and residents on training program (including PGY1-5),in Peking University First Hospital were enrolled in this retrospective study.Questionnaire investigation was used to collect the information about their motivations and feelings to engage in clinical medical education,their training backgrounds in teaching ability,the difficulties they met and the helps they needed in clinical teaching.Main elements were compared between the attending physicians and residents,multivariable logistic regression analyses was used to determine the independent relative factors of their feelings,difficult experience and helps needed,what were focused by most of subjects.Results Effective rate of questionnaire investigation was 99.3％ (437/440 questionnaire distributed).The actual sampling size in attending physicians population was 66.3％ (126/190 peoples),and was 61.1％ (311/509 peoples)in residents.In all subjects (n =437),84.7％ (370 people) were actually engaged in clinical education,55.6％ (243 people)thought that they were passively involved,and these ratio were significant higher in attending physicians population than in residents (P＜0.05).Engaging in clinical teaching was estimated as a favorite by 67.7 ％ (296 people),90.4％ (395 people) considered that clinical teaching is beneficial to the improvement of themselves,and 50.3％ (220 people) thought that they need systemic training in education,no significant difference was found between attending physicians and residents in terms of self-identification ratio in above confessions.Trainings in education was significantly more experienced in attending physicians than residents (P＜0.05),and the difficult experience of "insufficient in knowledge and ability to support the clinical teaching" was significant more frequently reported by residents than attending physicians(P＜0.05),multivariable logistic regression analyses showed that actual engaging in clinical teaching(OR:2.733,P=0.001),and the motivations to engage in clinical education,for self-improvement in competence (OR:5.677,P =0.000) ; enthusiasm for teaching the doctors of next generation (OR:4.752,P=0.000),were the independent enabling factors producing the feelings of favorite in clinical education.Years on working or on training (OR:0.752,P =0.003),educational background (OR:0.581,P=0.001),and the motivations to engage in clinical education,for self-improvement in competence (OR:1.833,P =0.005),enthusiasm for teaching the doctors of next generation (OR:1.863,P =0.026),were the independent relative factors for the difficult experience of "insufficient in knowledge and ability to support clinical teaching".However,the motivations to engage in clinical education,for self-improvement in competence(OR:1.920,P =0.002)was the unique independent enabling factor for the need of systemic training in education.Conclusions The ratios of engaging in clinical teaching and having trainings in education were significant lower in residents than in attending physicians.The need for systemic training in education did not increased in junior residents who were more likely to be less self-confident in teaching due to the shortage of knowledge and ability,but it did in the population who engaged in clinical education for self-improvement.Encouraging the residents to teach,training the residents to teach and advocating the idea of "teaching is learning" in the residents population,would be enable and beneficial for augmentation of residents teaching level.