Research on the Rationality of Ecological Service from Urban Forests and Paddy Fields: A Case of Shanghai

JI Xin,LIU Ping-yang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-2104.2011.07.021
2011-01-01
Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment
Abstract:Urban forest construction plays a critical role in meeting the growing demand for ecological service and improving the environmental quality in urban areas,but it is not the only choice.However,the cost effectiveness problem was often ignored in previous researches and practice.Based on the case study of Shanghai urban forests,this paper analyses the cost effectiveness of renting land for urban forest plantation,and finds out that Shanghai urban forests are faced with both the challenge of high cost and limited capability of ecological service,due to the marketization of plantation.Based on the comparison of eco-service functions between forest ecosystem and paddy fields,it's argued that paddy fields and forests have different advantages.Paddy fields work better in flood prevention and watershed protection,while being more fragile to human activities.In fact,paddy fields and river nets have been the major eco-service source of Shanghai Metropolis.Under the principle of cost effectiveness,it's pointed out that the supply of urban ecological service should not over-rely on urban forests,but focus more on the integration of different eco-elements according to local conditions,including paddy fields,river nets,and so on.More efforts should be put on the protection and restoration of paddy-field ecosystem,and the optimization of urban forests.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?