Abstract:Purpose Using a sample of 9,898 firm-year observations from 1,821 unique Chinese listed firms over the period from 2004 to 2019, this study aims to investigate whether the market rewards meeting or beating analyst earnings expectations (MBE). Design/methodology/approach The authors use an event study methodology to capture market reactions to MBE. Findings The authors document a stock return premium for beating analyst forecasts by a wide margin. However, there is no stock return premium for firms that meet or just beat analyst forecasts, suggesting that the market is skeptical of earnings management by these firms. This market underreaction is more pronounced for firms with weak external monitoring. Further analysis shows that meeting or just beating analyst forecasts is indicative of superior future financial performance. The authors do not find firms using earnings management to meet or just beat analyst forecasts. Research limitations/implications The authors provide evidence of market underreaction to meeting or just beating analyst forecasts, with the market's over-skepticism of earnings management being a plausible mechanism for this phenomenon. Practical implications The findings of this study are informative to researchers, market participants and regulators concerned about the impact of analysts and earnings management and interested in detecting and constraining managers' earnings management. Originality/value The authors provide new insights into how the market reacts to MBE by showing that the market appears to focus on using meeting or just beating analyst forecasts as an indicator of earnings management, while it does not detect managed MBE. Meeting or just beating analyst forecasts is commonly used as a proxy for earnings management in the literature. However, the findings suggest that it is a noisy proxy for earnings management.

Do Analysts Overreact to Extreme Good News in Earnings?

Games for Attention: Evidence from Analysts’ Earnings Forecasts for U.S.-Listed Foreign Firms

Are Accounting Estimate Changes Associated with an Aggressive Earnings Effect? Empirical Evidence

Expectation disarray: Analysts' growth forecast anomaly in China

Earnings management and analyst forecast

Does the market reward meeting or beating analyst earnings forecasts? Empirical evidence from China

Comparing with the average: Reference points and market reactions to above-average earnings surprises

Stock Dividend and Analyst Optimistic Bias in Earnings Forecast

Do Management Forecasts Dampen Analysts' Expectations?

Does Accounting Conservatism Affect Analysts'Earnings Forecast?——Evidence from Chinese Stock Market

The Superiority and Disciplining Role of Independent Analysts

China's Analysts Earning Forecast Errors and Home Advantage

Accurate Forecasts Attract Clients; Biased Forecasts Keep Them Happy

Analysts' forecast anchoring and discontinuous market reaction: evidence from China

Doing good in periods of high uncertainty: Economic policy uncertainty, corporate social responsibility, and analyst forecast error

Analyst sentiment and earning forecast bias in financial markets

Media Coverage and Underreaction-Related Anomalies

Social media discussion and the market reaction to earnings announcements: evidence from China

Do Managers Always Know Better? The Relative Accuracy of Management and Analyst Forecasts

The Earnings Announcement Return Cycle

Attention and Underreaction-Related Anomalies