The Clinical Pregnancy Outcome of Artificial Insemination by Donor (AID) and in Vitro Fertilization with Donor Semen (IVF-D) Treatment

王海燕,乔杰,刘平,罗莉,白泉,陈新娜,高凌,王晓凤

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-9534.2007.03.054

2007-01-01

Abstract:Objective: To analyze the clinical pregnancy outcome of artificial insemination by donor(AID) and in vitro fertilization with donor semen(IVF-D)treatment and investigate the best treatment for infertility by frozen donor semen.Methods: To analyze the clinical pregnancy outcome of AID treatment for 686 patients and IVF-D treatment for 93 patients from November 2004 to June 2006 in our hospital and to investigate the factors affecting the pregnancy rates of AID and IVF-D treatment.Results: We gave 686 patients AID treatment by intracervical insemination(ICI)for 1309 cycles.The clinical pregnancy rate per cycle was 16.88%(221/1309).The pregnancy rate per cycle of AID treatment was 19.89%(37/186)when we gave patients one time insemination before ovulation.The pregnancy rate per cycle of AID treatment was 14.46%(134/927)when we gave patients one time insemination after ovulation.The pregnancy rate per cycle of AID treatment was 25.51%(50/196)when we gave patients two times insemination after and before ovulation.There was a significant difference between the three kinds of insemination timing(χ2=15.49,P=0.001).The pregnancy rate per cycle of AID treatment by two times insemination treatment was best.The pregnancy rate of one time insemination before ovulation was better.The pregnancy rate of one time insemination after ovulation was lower.The cumulative pregnancy rate at the third AID cycles was 60.2%(153/254).We gave the 686 patients IVF-D treatment for 135 cycles.The pregnancy rate of fresh IVF-D cycles was 53.76%(50/93),the pregnancy rate of frozen IVF-D cycles was 50%(21/42),the average pregnancy rate per IVF-D cycle was 52.59%(71/135).The singleton pregnancy rate was higher in AID cycles than that in IVF-D cycles(91.86% versus 60.56%;χ2=39.65,P=0.001).The multiple pregnancy rate in AID cycles was lower than that in IVF-D cycles(1.36% versus 26.77%;χ2=68.4,P=0.001).There was no significant difference in ectopic pregnancy rate between AID and IVF-D cycles(0 versus 1.41%,Fisher exact test,P=0.24).There was no significant difference in spontenous abortion pregnancy rate between AID and IVF-D cycles(6.79% versus 11.27%;χ2=1.49,P=0.22).The pregnancy rate in AID cycles was lower than that in IVF-D cycles(16.88%versus 52.59%;χ2=96.73,P=0.001).Conclusion: Two times insemination treatment in AID cycles by ICI was simple and pregnancy rate was satisfactory.There was a higher pregnancy rate and higher multiple pregnancy rate in IVF-D cycles than that in AID cycles.