Experimental study on volume calculation accuracy by ultrasonography: a comparison between three dimensional volumetry and two dimensional formulization

YANG Su-guo,ZHANG Jian-quan,YANG Yu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-9011.2012.11.056
2012-01-01
Journal of Medical Imaging
Abstract:Objective To investigate the difference of volume calculation accuracy between three-dimensional volumetry and two dimensional formulization by using ultrasonography on experimental models.Methods A pare of 19 balloon models were set up in group A and group B.The balloons were filled in 19 different matching scales of amount,with saline in group A and with SonoVue micro-bubbles solution in group B.They were sealed and embedded in ultrasound gel container for ultrasound scanning.For three-dimensional data acquisition,an RAB 2-5-D probe available on Voluson-E8 ultrasound set(GE medical Co.,America) was used.The intrinsic VOCAL technique was applied for processing the volume data in a subtle rotation step of 6 degrees to yield the volume value of each balloon(i.e.3D-volume),and meanwhile multi-planar technique was used to produce three perpendicular planes for maximum length determinations.The three lengths for each balloon were citated for volume calculation based on spheroid formula(i.e.2D-volume).Results 3D-volume and 2D-volume were successfully calculated concomitantly for each balloon.3D-volume value was highly close to the actual amount of filling liquid in each balloon,with superiority in group A.2D-volume value was biased in over-estimation to the actual amount of filling liquid in each balloon,especially in group B.The bias of 2D volumetry was greater than that of 3D volumetry in a significant statistical difference(t=5.4913,P<0.001).3D volume values between group A and group B were proved in a mean difference of(12.33 ±7.67) ml(t=7.008,P<0.001) with the values greater in group B.Conclusion 3D-volumetry with VOCAL software can help achieve volumes much closer to the actual volume of object than 2D-volumetry.Proper and precise delineation along the inner border of region of interest is essential and critical while performing VOCAL processing.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?