Abstract:How should the government design a welfare-optimizing taxation policy in the scenario that individuals' utility is reference-dependent, determined in part by comparison between others' consumption and their own? Such socially reference-dependent utility tends to yield lower social welfare, since workers must increase their labor supply to support consumption which is partially 'neutralized' in their utility by the consumption of other members of society. By analyzing the government's taxation policy in a general equilibrium framework, our model shows that while a non-distortionary (ie. lump-sum) tax preserves this intuitive result, an optimized flat-rate income tax generates a striking result in which consumer welfare can be in fact increasing in the intensity of social comparison as long as the intensity is not too high. By mitigating the workers' incentive to over-work through the income-based tax, we show that the flat-rate income tax can outperform the lump-sum tax welfare-wise in the presence of social comparison, challenging the conventional wisdom on distortionary taxes. We also conduct comparisons between the two types of taxation policies in terms of public goods provision, labor supply and consumption. The findings provide insight on optimal taxation policy design under the realistic scenario that individuals in society have socially reference-dependent preferences.

Optimal Commodity Tax and Excess Burden

Optimal Indirect Taxation under Imperfect Competition

Optimal Indirect Taxes and Subsidies under Imperfect Competition

Commodity Taxation and Vertically Differentiation with Network Externality

Optimal commodity taxation when households earn multiple incomes

Optimal Taxation with Misperception on Prices

Optimal Mixed Taxation with Misperceptions of Prices

The Optimal Export Tax for a Primary Commodity in a Vertical Market

Ad Valorem Tax and the Cumulated Output of Exhaustible Resources——Based on the Modification of the Hotelling Model

Commodity tax competition with consumption externalities

Optimal taxation and the Domar-Musgrave effect

Lump-sum tax or flat income tax? Welfare implications of taxation policy in the presence of social comparison

The Studies on Optimized Macro Tax Burden,Structure of Public Expenditure and Consumption Growth Based on Models of Endogenous Growth

Optimal Taxation and Intergovernmental Transfer in A Dynamic Model with Multiple Levels of Government

Tariffs versus Quotas under Market Price Uncertainty

Welfare Implications of Switching to Consumption Taxation

Optimal In-Kind Redistribution

Unit Vs. Ad Valorem Taxes under Revenue Maximization

Foreign competition and optimal privatization with excess burden of taxation

Optimal Model of Anti-Dumping Tax Rate under Complete Information