Can Sperm-Injected In-Vitro Matured (IVM) Oocytes Produce Viable Pregnancies?

A. Dudkiewicz,Y. Zhou,M. Novotny,H. H. Kim,A. Caruso,D. Cohen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2007.07.928

IF: 6.7

2007-01-01

Fertility and Sterility

Abstract:To compare the developmental and clinical capacity of MII oocytes subjected to ICSI on the day of retrieval (Day-0) with sibling oocytes matured in-vitro and sperm injected on Day-1. Retrospective analysis. A total of 46 ICSI cycles, comprising the following stages: 273 MII, 85 MI and 114 GV oocytes, were compared with 149 ICSI cycles without IVM. Mature denuded MII oocytes were sperm injected 4–6 h post-retrieval. Immature MI and GV oocytes were cultured overnight (24–28 h) in P-1 containing 10% SPS in an atmosphere of 5.5% CO2, 6% O2 and balance N2 to attain the MII stage prior to ICSI. Early embryo development was observed the following day with transfer of embryos alone or combined with oocytes injected on the day of retrieval. Embryos were transferred on Day-3 using Wallace Catheters. Pregnancies were confirmed with ultrasound approximately 4 weeks post-transfer. Statistical analysis of data was performed using t-test or Fisher's exact test. Regarding IVM, 87% of MI oocytes and 57% of GV oocytes matured to MII following overnight culture. Of these post-ICSI, no significant difference in 2-PN rate between the MI- vs. GV-matured oocytes was observed, 52% vs. 60%, respectively; whereas, the 2-PN rate (71%) of the in-vivo matured sibling oocytes was significantly higher compared to the MI oocytes. No significant difference was noted in the cleavage rate (69%) between the IVM groups; however, the rate was significantly higher (96%) in the fertilized in-vivo matured oocytes. No significant difference could be detected in the D-2 or D-3 developmental scores between the IVM embryos and the in-vivo matured siblings. The average number of embryos transferred in the following groups (IVM, ICSI only, mixed group, and ICSI cycles without IVM) was 1.7, 2.7, 3.2, and 3.2, respectively; the clinical pregnancy rates were 0%, 24%, 6% and 30%, respectively. In 21 cases where IVM ICSI fresh embryos were transferred, either alone (3 cycles) or mixed (18 cycles) only one clinical pregnancy resulted - this occurred in the mixed group containing both IVM and in-vivo matured oocytes. Furthermore, frozen embryo transfers (7 cycles) containing embryos from IVM (2) or mixed (5) did not result in a pregnancy. Our results indicate that unless the parameters of IVM with respect to the timing of ICSI are modified, it is very unlikely that transferring IVM oocytes followed by ICSI the next day can be used to rescue cycles with immature oocytes.