Potent antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity of a V2-specific antibody is not sufficient for protection of macaques against SIV challenge
Michael W. Grunst,Hwi Min Gil,Andres G. Grandea,Brian J. Snow,Raiees Andrabi,Rebecca Nedellec,Iszac Burton,Natasha M. Clark,Sanath Kumar Janaka,Nida K. Keles,Ryan V. Moriarty,Andrea M. Weiler,Saverio Capuano,Christine M. Fennessey,Thomas C. Friedrich,Shelby L. O’Connor,David H. O’Connor,Aimee T. Broman,Brandon F. Keele,Jeffrey D. Lifson,Lars Hangartner,Dennis R. Burton,David T. Evans
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1011819
IF: 7.464
2024-01-23
PLoS Pathogens
Abstract:Fc-mediated antibody effector functions, such as antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC), can contribute to the containment HIV-1 replication but whether such activities are sufficient for protection is unclear. We previously identified an antibody to the variable 2 (V2) apex of the HIV-1 Env trimer (PGT145) that potently directs the lysis of SIV-infected cells by NK cells but poorly neutralizes SIV infectivity. To determine if ADCC is sufficient for protection, separate groups of six rhesus macaques were treated with PGT145 or a control antibody (DEN3) by intravenous infusion followed five days later by intrarectal challenge with SIV mac 239. Despite high concentrations of PGT145 and potent ADCC activity in plasma on the day of challenge, all animals became infected and viral loads did not differ between the PGT145- and DEN3-treated animals. To determine if PGT145 can protect against a neutralization-sensitive virus, two additional groups of six macaques were treated with PGT145 and DEN3 and challenged with an SIV mac 239 variant with a single amino acid change in Env (K180S) that increases PGT145 binding and renders the virus susceptible to neutralization by this antibody. Although there was no difference in virus acquisition, peak and chronic phase viral loads were significantly lower and time to peak viremia was significantly delayed in the PGT145-treated animals compared to the DEN3-treated control animals. Env changes were also selected in the PGT145-treated animals that confer resistance to both neutralization and ADCC. These results show that ADCC is not sufficient for protection by this V2-specific antibody. However, protection may be achieved by increasing the affinity of antibody binding to Env above the threshold required for neutralization. Antibodies that bind to the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein (Env) on virions can neutralize viral infectivity. Antibodies may also bind to Env on the surface of virus-infected cells and recruit immune cells to eliminate the productively infected cells through a process known as antibody dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC). In rare instances, certain antibodies are capable of mediating ADCC despite negligible neutralizing activity. Such antibodies are thought to have contributed to the modest protection observed in the RV144 HIV-1 vaccine trial and in some nonhuman primate studies. One antibody, PGT145, was found to cross-react with simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) and to mediate potent ADCC against SIV-infected cells despite weak neutralization of viral infectivity. We therefore tested if the potent ADCC activity of PGT145 could protect rhesus macaques against mucosal challenge with pathogenic SIV. PGT145 did not protect against wild-type SIV mac 239, but did protect against an SIV mac 239 variant with a single amino acid substitution in Env (K180S) that increases antibody binding to Env and makes the virus susceptible to neutralization. Thus, while ADCC may contribute to protection against immunodeficiency viruses through the elimination of productively infected cells, the higher affinity of Env binding necessary for potent neutralization is a critical determinant of antibody-mediated protection.
microbiology,virology,parasitology