Surgical treatment and approaches selection of thoracolumbar disc herniations

QI Qiang,CHEN Zhongqiang,LIU Zhongjun

2006-01-01

Abstract:Objective:To evaluate the surgical approaches and their correspondant outcomes of thoracolumbar disc herniations.Method:A retrospective review was performed on 38 patients with thoracolumbar disc herniation treated surgically between 1992 and 2000.There were 27 male and 11 female with the mean age of 44 years old(from 20 to 65 years old).The duration of symptoms was from 3 months to 11 years,averaging 34 months.There were 30 patients treated with anterior approach,of these,15 were treated with the combination of instrumentation.5 patients were treated with posterolateral approach(costotranversectomy).3 patients were managed with posterior approach(laminectomy). Result:The anterior approach had an excellent visualization on both anterior and anterolateral part of vertebral canal,which permits safer decompression and dural manipulation.The complications of anterior approach group included intraoperative pleural tear in 2 patients,peritoneal tear in 1 patient,dural laceration in 2 patients and postoperative chest effusion in 2 patients,pneumothorax in 1 patient,pneumonia in 1 patient,CSF leakage in 1 patient.No neurological complications were documented.Compared with the anterior approach,the posterolateral approach had less visualization for the surgeon to expose the ventral site of both dura and spinal cord,and allowed less safe dural manipulation.There were intraoperative pleural tear in 2 patients,with no postoperative neurological complications in this group.For the laminectomy group,the stretch of the spinal cord could not be avoided during the surgery.In this posterior approach group,there were neurological complications dated in 2 patients with neurological function of lower limbs worsened postoperatively.With an average of 5.8 years(4~12 years) follow-up,according to the Macnab′s and Otani′s criteria,there were 17 patients(44.7%) with excellent outcome,15 patients(39.5%) with good,5 patients(13.1%) with fair and 1 patient(2.7%) with poor outcome.Conclusion:The anterior approach can acquire excellent visualization and allow safe decompression and dural manipulation,which is the principle selcetion of thoracolumbar disc herniation,while the posterolateral approach is indicated for the patients with neclea pulps protruding extremely lateral,and the posterior laminectomy is the contraindication for this type of surgery.