On the Legal Effect of the Disposition of Nominee Holding by Registered Shareholders
Mo Ruoyun,Liu Kaixiang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-3275.2023.02.008
2023-01-01
Abstract:As for the legal effect of the disposition of nominee holding by registered shareholders, there used to be a big and long-time debate in the academic circle until the final decision was made in Article 25 of the Company Law Interpretation III,which regulates it by referring to the bona fide acquisition with the intentiong to balance the interests of dormant contributors, registered shareholders and external third parties.However, it implies that registered shareholders have no right to dispose nominee holding, which shakes the standard for determining the qualification of shareholders in the nominee shareholding established by Article 24.In the case of nominee shareholding, it is reasonable to adopt the formality theory as the standard, which is not only to follow the principles of Rechtsschein Theorie and Public Exposure Theorie and conducive to the logical self-consistency of the company law system, but also can better balance the risks and interests of all parties and curb the abnormal phenomenon of excessive nominee shareholding in commercial practice.As a result, the legal relationship of nominee holding should be subject to the Contract Law and not legally binding on the external third party.Therefore, registered shareholders, who obtain the shareholder qualification, have right to dispose nominee holding, even if it is not approved by the dormant contributors.On the other hand, dormant contributors can only claim contractual rights to the registered shareholders, and cannot become a shareholder without the explicit naming procedure.