Abstract:Research Summary Previous studies on initial public offerings (IPOs) in mature stock markets have documented that high-reputation underwriters primarily work with high-quality firms and vice versa-that is, they are paired through a quality-matching mechanism. We propose that in a nascent stock market, a pricing mechanism may also play a role, through which pricing (the underwriting fee) sets the pairing. We examine these two mechanisms in the context of China's ChiNext stock exchange, which was launched in 2009 and experienced dramatic regulatory improvements in 2012-2013. With data on IPOs in 2009-2017, we find evidence to support the pricing mechanism's effect before the regulatory improvements and the quality-matching mechanism's effect after the improvements. We contribute to the literature by developing an evolutionary view on the pairing mechanisms between important capital market participants. Managerial Summary In a mature stock market, underwriter reputation signals the underlying quality of initial public offering (IPO) firms to external investors because high-reputation underwriters primarily work with high-quality IPO firms and vice versa. We find that in a nascent stock market before the market experiences regulatory improvements, underwriters and IPO firms are paired through a pricing mechanism. That is, underwriters with higher reputation charge higher underwriting fees, and IPO firms with lower quality pay higher fees. Since the pricing mechanism rather than the quality-matching mechanism sets the pairing, underwriter reputation does not have a signaling effect. Instead, we find that higher underwriting fees signal lower quality of IPO firms. Our findings shed important insights on how market participants are paired in other nascent markets, nascent technology fields and industries.

Price Range and Strategic Allocation in IPO Bookbuilding

IPO Offer Price Regulation, Financial Reporting Quality, and IPO Overpricing

Bayesian piecewise stochastic frontier model to estimate initial public offering pricing efficiency under issuance policy reforms

The reform of IPO bookbuilding mechanism and IPO anomalies in China stock market: Evidence from the bidding of institutional investors

Rent Seeking, Brokerage Commissions, and Pricing and Share Allocation in Initial Public Offerings

Modeling Short-Term Post-Offering Price-Volume Relationships Using Bayesian Change-Point Panel Quantile Regression

Heterogeneous Beliefs, Market Environment and IPO Underpricing

High IPO Price of Stocks in Small-and Medium-Sized Board and Second Board Market

IPO Underpricing and Limited Attention: Theory and Evidence

Uncertainty of Political Subsidy, Heterogeneous Beliefs, and IPO Anomalies

IPO Pricing Efficiency and Ownership Structure: Evidence from China

Information quality and IPO underpricing: The role of underwriter pricing and allocation powers

IPO Underpricing and Information Quality of Prospectuses

Institutional Investors’ Cognitive Constraints During Initial Public Offerings

Limited Attention, Legalized Bribery and the Initial Public Offering Process

Underwriter,Cooperation Relationship and IPO Underpricing: Analysis from Multiple Agency Theory

The JOBS Act and IPO underpricing

Who Do You Take to Tango? Examining Pairing Mechanisms Between Underwriters and Initial Public Offering Firms in a Nascent Stock Market

The Interaction between IPO Earnings Management Incentive and Underwriter's Choice Decision and Regulatory Inspiration—Research Based on Bilateral Matching Model

Does Investor Sentiment Have Certain Impacts on IPO Underpricing Rate?